Research / Open questions
Open questions
Unresolved questions recorded in the canonical corpus — surfaced, not generated. 42 documents carry open questions.
Requirements — accountability and implementation tracking
- ## Open questions
Requirements — agenda and remit authority
- ## Open questions
Requirements — decision methods and dissent
- ## Open questions
Requirements — evidence and deliberation
- ## Open questions
Requirements — inclusion and accessibility
- ## Open questions
Requirements — governance authority versus software permission
- ## Open questions
Requirements — mandate types and receiving-authority response
- ## Open questions
Requirements — membership and term model
- ## Open questions
Requirements — risk matrix
- | Risk | Stage | Impact | Mitigation requirement | Residual/open question | Evidence basis |
Requirements — selection model requirements
- ## Open questions
CA-R3 — interoperability seams
- | OpenDLP | HTTP API | — | — | — | not evidenced (open question) | — | — |
CA-A1 synthesis — architecture and contracts
- ## Open questions deferred to implementation/operator
UK sortition, citizens' assembly and people's assembly landscape
- Evidence labels per RESEARCH-METHOD.md: Observed (official/primary), Claimed (organiser self-description), Evaluation (external/academic), Analysis (Cicada synthesis), Open question.
- ## 10. Implications and open questions for Cicada
Case study — Assemble / House of the People
- Evidence grading follows RESEARCH-METHOD.md. Labels: Observed (official/primary), Claimed (organiser self-description), Evaluation (external/academic), Analysis (Cicada synthesis), Open question.
- Claimed: weighting across age, geography, gender, income, ethnicity, disability (SRC-0064). Targets and benchmark sources not published in retrieved material (Open question).
- Observed/Claimed: three-day facilitated deliberation on local-assembly outcomes and expert input (SRC-0063, SRC-0067). Facilitation governance details not published (Open question).
- Observed: the organisation publishes model descriptions and outputs; lottery mechanics documentation is thin (SRC-0063, SRC-0064). Open question: participant data handling for the lottery and delegate nomination.
- Open question: independence of the draw, scale of the applicant pool, delegate nomination mechanics, and governance accountability of the project.
- ## 20. Cicada relevance / open questions
Brussels permanent citizens' assembly for the climate (2022– )
- Reports compiled by Bruxelles Environnement after each cycle and tracked by relevant regional administrations (SRC-0132). A three-year bilan published March 2026 (100+ proposals) (SRC-0133). No statutory response deadline evidenced (open question).
- ## 20. Cicada relevance / open questions
- Open: ordonnance citation; response deadlines; member privacy rules; whether GDPR special-category bar applies to its criteria (SRC-0032 scope question).
Case study — Brussels deliberative committees (commissions délibératives)
- Evidence grading follows RESEARCH-METHOD.md. Labels: Observed (official/primary), Claimed (organiser self-description), Evaluation (external/academic), Analysis (Cicada synthesis), Open question.
- Cumulative figure ">220" reported by RTBF; primary-source-verified sum 204 (SRC-0034). Estimated cost ~€90,000 per committee (Brussels Parliament via RTBF, SRC-0034). Implementation flows through ordinary parliamentary instruments; recommendation-level implementation rates are not yet systematically catalogued (open question).
- Open questions: MP attendance/attrition per committee; what share of recommendations reach ordonnance/decree stage; whether citizen-only anonymity in voting has measurable effects.
- ## 20. Cicada relevance / open questions
- Open questions: implementation conversion rates; MP attrition; how the second-stage stratified draw is technically executed and by whom; whether the model survives majority change (institutionalisation depth vs actual usage frequency).
Citizens' Assembly of Scotland (2019–2022 response)
- Adults resident in Scotland; exclusions not fully extracted into this record (open question).
- Quota criteria applied at recruitment — including gender, age, geography and deprivation-related criteria per the research report; full strata table not extracted (open question — report SRC-0045 holds the detail).
- Support provisions documented in the research report; detail not extracted (open question). The COVID transition is itself an inclusion data point: the assembly moved from in-person weekends to online deliberation mid-mandate.
- Report and response public; member-level privacy arrangements not extracted (open question).
- Online deliberation platform used post-COVID suspension; platform detail not extracted (open question).
- ## 20. Cicada relevance / open questions
Case study — Ireland Citizens' Assemblies
- Evidence grading follows RESEARCH-METHOD.md. Labels used inline: Observed (official/primary), Claimed (organiser self-description), Evaluation (external/academic), Analysis (Cicada synthesis), Open question.
- Open question: the underlying address database used for household sampling (the official account is in Appendix D of the Drugs Use final report, SRC-0014).
- Observed: subsequent assemblies produced reports on gender equality (2021), Dublin local government (2022), biodiversity loss (2023) and drugs use (2023), each referred to Oireachtas/Government response processes (SRC-0011). Open question: a systematic recommendation-level implementation audit across all six bodies is not yet part of this record.
- Open question: cost per assembly; measured long-run implementation rates per recommendation.
- ## 20. Cicada relevance / open questions
- Open questions: who operates the second-stage draw and how is it independently verified; exact address-frame provider for household invitations; honorarium amount; measured implementation rates per recommendation.
Case study — Climate Assembly UK
- Evidence grading follows RESEARCH-METHOD.md. Labels: Observed (official/primary), Claimed (organiser self-description), Evaluation (external/academic), Analysis (Cicada synthesis), Open question.
- Observed: no statutory response duty — the committee's stated intent was the follow-up mechanism. The BEIS committee ran a follow-up inquiry and published a Government response as part of its scrutiny (SRC-0039). Open question: systematic tracking of which recommendations influenced committee reports or government policy is not consolidated in a single official record.
- Evaluation: a member-experience chapter is included in the official report (SRC-0038); independent academic evaluations exist but were not catalogued in this pass (Open question).
- ## 20. Cicada relevance / open questions
- Open questions: consolidated implementation tracking; named online tooling; independent evaluations; cost data.
Case study — Leeds Climate Change Citizens' Jury
- Evidence grading follows RESEARCH-METHOD.md. Labels: Observed (official/primary), Claimed (organiser self-description), Evaluation (external/academic), Analysis (Cicada synthesis), Open question.
- Observed: the jury report records member-support arrangements; granular payment/expenses detail is not fully catalogued here (Open question) (SRC-0051).
- Observed: 12 recommendations published; council committed to respond; jury opposition to airport expansion reported widely (SRC-0051, SRC-0053). Open question: documented conversion of recommendations into adopted council policy is limited in retrieved sources.
- ## 20. Cicada relevance / open questions
- Open questions: compensation detail; response-tracking artefacts; longer-term uptake.
Case study — Newham permanent citizens' assembly
- Evidence grading follows RESEARCH-METHOD.md. Labels: Observed (official/primary), Claimed (organiser self-description), Evaluation (external/academic), Analysis (Cicada synthesis), Open question.
- Observed: the council committed to supporting participation; detailed honorarium/expense arrangements are not consolidated in the retrieved official pages (Open question — the Commission report discusses inclusive participation commitments) (SRC-0048, SRC-0049).
- Observed: recommendations agreed by the assembly and presented to the council; formal voting mechanics are not fully catalogued in retrieved pages (Open question).
- Observed: council pages publish the model and topic-selection route (SRC-0047); member privacy arrangements not yet catalogued in detail (Open question).
- Observed: first assembly produced recommendations on greening the borough with a formal council response route; a second assembly ran with the rotation model (SRC-0047, SRC-0048, SRC-0049). Open question: recommendation-level implementation tracking and long-run cohort continuity (post-2022 activity, including reported mobilisation for a further assembly) require continued monitoring.
- Open question: attrition, payment, replacement mechanics and selection audit detail are less thoroughly published than Climate Assembly UK.
Case study — Ostbelgien permanent Citizens' Dialogue (Bürgerdialog)
- Evidence grading follows RESEARCH-METHOD.md. Labels: Observed (official/primary), Claimed (organiser self-description), Evaluation (external/academic), Analysis (Cicada synthesis), Open question.
- Observed: the 2022 internal evaluation seminar generated changes enacted in the April 2024 decree amendment — the model is iteratively revised rather than fixed (SRC-0020). Specific amendment contents not yet catalogued in this record (open question).
- Evaluation: the UCL team's five-year reflection (SRC-0022) and Band 23 (SRC-0023) are the authoritative critique sources; detailed findings not yet extracted into this record (open question).
- Open question: measured implementation rate of recommendations across completed assemblies; response rate at phase 1.
- ## 20. Cicada relevance / open questions
- Open questions: phase-2 draw mechanics; response rates; decree-amendment detail; implementation-rate measurement method; whether a jurisdiction of ~78k scales to larger populations.
Case study — Paris Citizens' Assembly (Assemblée citoyenne de Paris)
- Evidence grading follows RESEARCH-METHOD.md. Labels: Observed (official/primary), Claimed (organiser self-description), Evaluation (external/academic), Analysis (Cicada synthesis), Open question.
- Observed: primarily the Paris electoral lists — ~1.35 million registered electors; for promotion 1, 10,000 were randomly selected from the lists (SRC-0025). Complementary frames cover groups outside the electoral lists: the carte citoyenne for 16–17-year-olds and a dedicated channel for non-EU residents (SRC-0028, SRC-0002). Open question: the register used to sample non-EU residents.
- Open question: official pages reviewed do not document participant payment, expenses or accessibility provisions. A dedicated general secretariat of city staff (Secrétariat général de l'Assemblée citoyenne) supports the work (SRC-0024).
- Observed: the bailiff's draw procès-verbal and the member list are published; the follow-up documents are public; droit de suite meetings are public (SRC-0002, SRC-0027). Open question: privacy arrangements for members during the mandate are not documented in the pages reviewed; whether deliberative phases are public.
- Implementation tracking is published (e.g. the March 2024 follow-up document listing progress per recommendation, SRC-0028). Claimed: the City cites adoption of all vœux/délibérations submitted to date; the droit de suite documents are the instrument for verifying actual delivery — recommendation-level implementation status exists but has not been extracted into this record (open question).
- Open questions: participant payment/accessibility; independent evaluations (no external academic evaluation has been catalogued in this record yet); member attrition rates; non-EU-resident sampling frame; the 2021 délibération text itself (legal terms of the assembly) not yet captured as a source.
Case study — Scotland's Climate Assembly
- Evidence grading follows RESEARCH-METHOD.md. Labels: Observed (official/primary), Claimed (organiser self-description), Evaluation (external/academic), Analysis (Cicada synthesis), Open question.
- Observed: selection targeted representativeness of the Scottish population on demographic criteria (the operations documentation and research report describe age, gender, geography, socio-economic and ethnicity-based targets) (SRC-0043, SRC-0044). Open question: the exact stratum set and benchmark sources are specified in the operations documentation more fully than catalogued here.
- Observed: support arrangements were set out in the operations and administration documentation, including expenses and measures to support inclusive participation (SRC-0043). Open question: precise honorarium rates and benefit-mitigation arrangements are not yet catalogued at the same detail as Climate Assembly UK.
- Observed: an evidence workstream provided learning materials, briefings and speaker input across the seven weekends; the government research report covers member experience of the evidence process (SRC-0044). Open question: advisory-board composition and speaker-selection governance for this assembly are documented in the assembly's own governance pages; catalogued partially.
- Observed: the assembly produced 16 goals and 81 recommendations through internal voting/consensus processes documented in its report (SRC-0043, SRC-0044). Members were additionally able to record dissenting positions in the report (SRC-0044). Open question: the precise voting thresholds and minority-statement mechanics merit extraction from the full report.
- Observed: 16 goals and 81 recommendations; formal ministerial response published December 2021 (SRC-0044). Open question: conversion rate of recommendations into adopted policy is not consolidated in an official tracking record.
Case study — Your Party (party-internal sortition and member democracy)
- Evidence grading follows RESEARCH-METHOD.md. Labels: Observed (official/primary), Claimed (organiser self-description), Evaluation (external/academic), Analysis (Cicada synthesis), Open question.
- Observed: regional assemblies and the crowd-editing tool were open to members (self-selected participation) (SRC-0061). The MOC was drawn from the membership — the published description records random selection conducted by the Sortition Foundation; the sampling frame used (e.g. all members vs volunteers) is not fully specified in public material (Open question) (SRC-0059).
- Observed: no public evidence that MOC selection applied stratification targets beyond membership of the party (Open question) (SRC-0059).
- Observed: MOC members described as volunteers; remote/online participation channels used for ballots (SRC-0059, SRC-0061). No payment details published (Open question).
- Observed: founding documents adopted at the November 2025 conference; MOC constituted January 2026 and CEC election oversight proceeded under the stated timeline (SRC-0059, SRC-0061). External evaluation of process integrity is not catalogued (Open question).
- Open question: MOC sampling frame, stratification, replacement rules and post-interim institutionalisation of sortition (if any) are not yet fully documented publicly.
Legislation — Brussels-Capital: ordonnance basis of the permanent climate citizens' assembly
- No statutory response deadline evidenced in reviewed sources; reports compiled by Bruxelles Environnement and followed by regional administrations (SRC-0132–SRC-0134). Open question: whether the ordonnance creates a formal response duty.
- Residents (live/work in the region), 65–100 drawn from 10,000 invitations; strata sex/age/residence/education/profession; €75/day (SRC-0133). Whether the GDPR special-category prohibition applied to the parliamentary commissions' decree (SRC-0032) also binds this assembly's criteria is unverified — different instrument, same region (open question).
- ## Analysis / open questions
- Open: ordonnance number/text; formal response duties; applicability of the special-category prohibition; evaluation provisions.
Legislation — Scotland: statutory citizens' climate assembly duty
- ## Analysis / open questions
- Open: whether the duty is one-off (singular assembly) or supports repeated convening — the instrument's phrasing around recurrence not extracted; statutory scope is climate-specific, unlike the non-statutory generalist CAS (SRC-0045).
Method — civic lottery methods
- Seed/witness model: deterministic draw + public seed + independent witness = reproducibility claim; OpenDLP's seed/witness ceremony is not fully documented (open question, `opendlp.md`).
Method — facilitation
- Facilitator discretion vs auditability: facilitation operates in the room, largely unrecorded — the corpus's least auditable stage. Mitigations: published method, facilitator codes, member feedback channels (practice-level, not evidenced as formal audit, open question).
Organisation — Assemble
- ## Open questions
Organisation — Involve
- ## Open questions
Organisation — Sortition Foundation
- ## Open questions
Software — CONSUL DEMOCRACY
- ## Limitations / open questions
Software — Dembrane Echo
- Licence: recorded by GitHub as "Other"/unasserted (NOASSERTION) — licence terms require direct verification at CA-R3 before any reuse consideration (SRC-0098). Open question.
- Not assessed in reviewed material beyond repo-level signals (Open questions: data handling, retention, API/export surface).
- ## Limitations / open questions
Software — Decidim
- Observed/Analysis: multilingual-first platform (crowdsourced translations); institutional deployments commonly pair it with offline channels; no offline/low-bandwidth mode found in reviewed docs (Open question).
- ## Limitations / open questions
Software — Loomio
- Widely used by cooperatives, civil-society groups and public bodies for group decision-making; not evidenced as the deliberation layer of a *sortitioned* assembly in this corpus (Open question).
- ## Limitations / open questions
Software — OpenDLP (Open Democratic Lottery Platform)
- Hosted SaaS operated by Sortition Foundation; self-hosting appears possible from the public repo but packaged deployment documentation was not verified in this pass (Open question).
- Observed: the underlying selection code is open source with a documented walkthrough enabling operators to run a selection independently (SRC-0076, SRC-0077). Random-seed handling, per-run audit artefacts and witness/attestation mechanics are not documented in the reviewed material (Open question — compare Decidim's explicit die-roll+witnesses seed record, SRC-0083).
- Observed: a "Data and the law" docs section exists but is marked "still to be written"; a User Data Agreement page exists (SRC-0074, SRC-0099). Data-handling assumptions therefore partially documented; GDPR material not yet published (Open question).
- Observed: CSV-based respondent and target inputs documented (SRC-0075). No public API documentation found in reviewed material (Open question). Docs repository is public: github.com/sortitionfoundation/opendlp-docs (SRC-0074).
- ## Limitations / open questions
Software — Panelot
- Website/service only: a public source repository matching `panelot` was not located in this pass (Open question; see limitations).
- Licence: described as open-source in maintainer publications but no licence file was verified (Open question — do not assume reuse rights).
- Observed: CSV in/out; no public API documentation found (Open question).
- ## Limitations / open questions
- Public source repository and licence for the hosted Panelot service not verified (Open question).
Software — Polis (Computational Democracy)
- ## Limitations / open questions
Software — Stanford Online Deliberation Platform
- Observed: hosted web platform, "limited alpha mode — limited capacity available to test/use"; access via the Stanford team, not self-hostable from published material (SRC-0096). Licence: not found in reviewed documentation — treat as unavailable for independent reuse until evidence changes (Open question).
- Observed: in-browser, no downloads; Chrome/Firefox desktop and Android (SRC-0096). Privacy/data model not publicly documented in reviewed material (Open question).
- ## Limitations / open questions
Theory — nested and multi-level assemblies
- Recall/removal and term limits apply differently to delegates (who can recall a delegate?) vs drawn members (removal for non-attendance only?) (open question across corpus).
Theory — permanent, recurring and rotating assemblies
- Repeat service: whether former members may be redrawn is a fairness/institutional-memory choice; undocumented in most corpus cases (open question).