Decision and dissent requirements
CA-R2 requirements record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Models how assemblies conclude and how disagreement is preserved. No voting method is mandated — the method is a governance parameter; the record obligations are constant.
Methods to represent
- Consensus — no formal vote; output presented as collectively held. Corpus practice: consensus-seeking as process, not necessarily closure (SRC-0116).
- Consent — absence of sustained objection (sociocratic-style); distinct from unanimity.
- Simple majority — >50% of votes cast.
- Supermajority — declared threshold (e.g. 66%); used where legitimacy requires breadth.
- Ranking — preferential ordering of options.
- Score voting — per-option scores aggregated.
- Secret ballot — individual votes unrecorded, aggregate published (CA UK used secure ballots, SRC-0038).
- Open vote — votes attributable.
- Recommendation support levels — per-recommendation strength of support published (Leeds tiers: strong/moderate/weak support, SRC-0047; Ireland published voting splits, SRC-0017).
- Abstention — a recorded position, not an absence of vote.
- Unresolved outcome — a no-decision is a legitimate, recordable output; the system must not force closure.
- Minority / dissent statement — attachable minority reports (Ireland, SRC-0017) and published dissent as first-class outputs.
Record obligations
Every decision event must preserve:
- question posed — exact wording, versioned;
- method used — the declared method and its parameters (threshold, ballot secrecy, rounds);
- electorate — which memberships were eligible to vote, at which timestamp;
- quorum — if applicable, the rule and whether it was met;
- result — counts/support levels as cast;
- dissent / minority position — recorded statements, published with the result;
- provenance — who administered, who counted/witnessed;
- timestamp / version — including re-runs or amended questions (never overwrite an earlier result).
Design constraints from the corpus
- Deliberation method and decision method are separate stages — consensus-seeking is a process; the ballot is a conclusion (
METHOD-COMPARISON.md, SRC-0116). - Strength-of-support recording is inconsistently implemented in the corpus — a documented weakness the model must fix by construction.
- Secret-ballot and open-vote must be per-decision parameters, not institution-wide constants (a body may vote openly on process and secretly on substance).
- The result object must never be editable by the administering or receiving authority after closure — corrections are new versions.
Open questions
- Whether recommendations should carry per-member positions where votes are open.
- Threshold defaults (there is no corpus answer — governance choice).
- How abstention vs absence is distinguished in reporting.