Evidence and deliberation requirements
CA-R2 requirements record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Institutional requirements for what members see and how they deliberate. Software may support the process; software does not own the judgement about evidence balance or political legitimacy — those judgements belong to named human/institutional actors whose choices must be recorded.
Evidence inputs
- Evidence submissions — register of submitted material (documents, testimony, data) with source, submission channel, and acceptance status.
- Experts — who was invited, by whom, under what selection rationale; expertise area; affiliations.
- Stakeholders — affected interests heard; how stakeholder standing was recognised.
- Participant-requested evidence — members’ right to call evidence (CA UK and Scotland evidence member-requested input, SRC-0038/SRC-0044); requests and their fulfilment recorded.
- Conflicts of interest — disclosures for experts, facilitators, and evidence sources; CA UK three-tier governance (Expert Leads + Advisory Panel + Academic Panel) is the corpus benchmark (SRC-0038).
- Balance / contestability — the record must show the balance assessment: who judged the evidence set balanced, under what process, and how challenges were handled. Adversarial/contested evidence presentation is preferable to curator-only framing (SRC-0100, SRC-0129).
- Evidence provenance — every item carries source, date, selection rationale, and disclosure metadata so members and the public can trace what was included and excluded and why.
Deliberation process
- Facilitation — facilitation method recorded; facilitator identity and assignment per session; the corpus flags facilitator influence as the least auditable stage (SRC-0106, SRC-0115) — structure and interventions must at least be documentable.
- Breakout groups — composition, assignment method (random/managed), facilitator mapping; breakouts are where facilitation power concentrates.
- Speaking opportunities — equality-of-voice is a recorded evaluative dimension (SRC-0102); records need not transcript everything but must support quality assessment.
- Online / offline / hybrid participation — corpus includes in-person, online transition under COVID (Citizens’ Assembly of Scotland), and hybrid; the model must represent participation modality per session/member.
- Accessibility — interpretation, translation, accessible materials and formats as delivered provisions (see
INCLUSION-ACCESSIBILITY.md). - Deliberative records — what is recorded vs what is protected. Brussels statutorily protects the deliberative space while publishing method and outputs (SRC-0030) — the corpus’s answer to the transparency-vs-protection conflict.
- Private / protected discussion — representable as a session property with a governance basis, not an admin convenience.
- Transparency — publishable artefacts: method, agenda, evidence register, outputs, support levels. Non-publishable by default: identifiable member speech in protected settings.
- Moderation — moderation actions (interventions, removals, timekeeping) recorded at least in aggregate; who moderates and under whose authority.
- Misinformation handling — correction/challenge procedure for contested claims in evidence or deliberation; recorded as an action with an actor.
Requirements
- An evidence register is a first-class object: items, sources, selection rationale, disclosures, member-requested status.
- Session records capture structure (agenda segment, facilitation model, modality, breakout composition) — not necessarily verbatim content.
- Balance assessment is a recorded governance judgement with a named assessor and review path — never an automated verdict.
- Deliberation must be representable across modalities (in-person, synchronous online, asynchronous, hybrid) without losing record continuity.
- The boundary between publishable deliberative record and protected deliberation must be an explicit governance declaration per institution.
Open questions
- How to measure facilitator influence without destroying protected deliberation.
- Whether evidence balance should be assessed by contested-presentation rules, panel review, or both.
- How member-requested evidence rights are bounded (scope, cost, timing).
Sources
research/methods/evidence-and-expert-governance.md,research/methods/deliberation-quality.md,research/methods/deliberation-risks-and-safeguards.md,research/methods/facilitation.md- SRC-0030, SRC-0038, SRC-0044, SRC-0054, SRC-0070, SRC-0100–SRC-0102, SRC-0106, SRC-0110, SRC-0111, SRC-0114–SRC-0116, SRC-0119, SRC-0129