Candidate assembly lifecycle model
CA-R2 requirements record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Defines the institutional lifecycle Cicada Assemblies must be able to represent. This is a lifecycle model, not a data model or architecture. Derived from the accepted CA-R1 corpus — see research/methods/METHOD-COMPARISON.md and research/software/CAPABILITY-LANDSCAPE.md.
eligible population
↓
sampling/invitation frame
↓
invitation
↓
response / opt-in
↓
stratified or other authorised selection
↓
reserve / replacement
↓
membership / term / onboarding
↓
agenda / remit
↓
evidence and submissions
↓
deliberation
↓
recommendation / decision / dissent
↓
receiving authority
↓
formal response
↓
implementation / rejection / modification
↓
follow-up / accountability
↓
completion / rotation / renewal
1. Eligible population
- Institutional purpose: define who may legitimately be selected (citizens, residents, members of an organisation, a defined polity).
- Required actors: commissioning/governing authority that sets eligibility rules; legal counsel where franchise/residency is contested.
- Required records: eligibility rule text, its authority, and the date it took effect.
- Governance decisions: residency vs citizenship; age floor; exclusions (e.g. sitting politicians — Brussels excludes elected members, SRC-0030).
- Audit/provenance: the eligibility rule is itself a governance artefact and must be attributable.
- Privacy implications: none directly — the population is a rule, not a list of named people.
- Accessibility/offline: none at this stage.
- Transitions: population → invitation frame.
- Unresolved choices: whether eligibility is per-assembly or institution-wide; how eligibility disputes are adjudicated.
2. Sampling / invitation frame
- Purpose: the concrete population from which invitations can actually be drawn — always narrower than the eligible population.
- Required actors: authority owning/procuring the frame (electoral register, National Register, Royal Mail PAF, contracted recruiter).
- Required records: frame type, coverage gap, procurement authority, date range.
- Governance decisions: which frame is acceptable given coverage gaps (register vs postal address database vs contracted quota recruitment — Ireland 2016-18 vs 2019+, SRC-0021).
- Audit/provenance: frame identity and coverage assessment must be recorded; frames are a known bias source (SRC-0120).
- Privacy: frame data is personal data under another authority’s control; Cicada should record the frame, not own it.
- Accessibility: postal and register frames have different exclusion profiles (unregistered residents, homeless populations).
- Transitions: frame → invitations.
- Unresolved choices: who may authorise frame use; how coverage gaps are disclosed publicly.
3. Invitation
- Purpose: approach a bounded subset of the frame with an offer to participate.
- Required actors: operator administering invitations; the institution whose name carries legitimacy.
- Required records: invitation population size, method (postal/register draw/digital), invitation weighting, dates, wording.
- Governance decisions: raw-probability invitations vs deprivation-weighted invitations (CA UK weighted by IMD, SRC-0038); household-vs-individual addressing.
- Audit/provenance: the invitation draw is the first random event — its method and seed/witness practice should be reproducible (currently under-documented corpus-wide).
- Privacy: contact data handling begins here; invitations are the first point where identifiable persons are processed.
- Accessibility/offline: postal invitation is the standard non-digital channel; response routes must include offline options.
- Transitions: invitations → response pool.
- Unresolved choices: reminder policy; whether invitation counts are fixed or adaptive to response rate.
4. Response / opt-in
- Purpose: form the respondent pool from which selection actually occurs.
- Required actors: respondents; administrators handling registration.
- Required records: invitation→registration funnel counts, declared strata data, consent records.
- Governance decisions: what data is collected at registration (strata vs special-category — Brussels GDPR prohibition vs UK consent model, SRC-0032/SRC-0122); opt-in vs opt-out.
- Audit/provenance: funnel must be reportable (invitations sent / registered / selected / seated).
- Privacy: highest-risk early stage — self-declared strata data, including potentially special-category data.
- Accessibility/offline: registration must not require internet (CA UK used postal registration; no reviewed software supports this, per CAPABILITY-LANDSCAPE).
- Transitions: respondent pool → authorised selection.
- Unresolved choices: incentive/reimbursement at response stage; handling of duplicate or assisted registrations.
5. Stratified or other authorised selection
- Purpose: produce the membership cohort (and reserves) from respondents under an authorised selection specification.
- Required actors: operator; witness/audit participants; the governance body that authorised the specification.
- Required records: the selection specification (strata, quotas, weights), the algorithm/method, seed or entropy source, witness record, run output, timestamp.
- Governance decisions: strata choice and quotas (legitimacy-contested, SRC-0109); attitudinal criteria permitted or prohibited (CA UK yes, Brussels no); oversampling policy.
- Audit/provenance: the run must be reproducible by an independent party given the published specification and seed; Panelot’s public computed-lottery practice is the corpus benchmark (SRC-0078–SRC-0080).
- Privacy: selection consumes respondent strata data; outputs should minimise what is published per member.
- Accessibility/offline: none at execution; but the published specification must be human-readable.
- Transitions: selection → members + reserves.
- Unresolved choices: leximin vs quota-fill algorithms; public ceremony vs sealed run; degree of operator discretion permitted (corpus suggests near-zero).
6. Reserve / replacement
- Purpose: maintain target composition when selected members decline, withdraw or are removed.
- Required actors: operator; governance authority approving replacement protocol.
- Required records: reserve list (ordered or stratified), replacement rules, each replacement event with reason class.
- Governance decisions: replacement by same-strata draw vs reserve ordering; how late replacements may occur.
- Audit/provenance: replacements are a manipulation surface — every replacement needs recorded provenance (who, when, under which rule).
- Privacy: reserves are not-yet members; their data retention needs an explicit rule.
- Accessibility: same as invitation.
- Transitions: reserves → members on replacement; reserves expire at cohort end.
- Unresolved choices: whether reserve composition is public; maximum replacement rate before re-selection.
7. Membership / term / onboarding
- Purpose: convert selected persons into seated members with defined terms.
- Required actors: members; secretariat/facilitation team; support services.
- Required records: membership roster, term dates, cohort identity, support provisions used, consents.
- Governance decisions: term length and stagger (Ostbelgien 18-month thirds rotation, SRC-0021; Paris annual cohorts, SRC-0027); repeat-service policy.
- Audit/provenance: roster changes must be logged; membership status transitions are auditable events.
- Privacy: members’ public vs private profile is a governance choice (Brussels protects deliberation, SRC-0030).
- Accessibility/offline: onboarding is where participation support is delivered — payment, care, accessibility, offline routes.
- Transitions: onboarding → active member; member → withdrawal/replacement/completion.
- Unresolved choices: whether membership records persist across cohorts (institutional memory) and under whose control.
8. Agenda / remit
- Purpose: establish what the assembly is authorised to consider.
- Required actors: agenda authority (commissioner, statute, citizens’ council, public vote — five corpus models).
- Required records: remit text, its authority and approval, question wording, amendments, exclusions with reasons.
- Governance decisions: the whole of agenda-setting — the corpus’s least-studied consequential power (agenda-setting record).
- Audit/provenance: remit wording and every amendment must carry provenance.
- Privacy: petitions may contain personal data; submission handling needs rules.
- Accessibility: public agenda input must not require digital-only channels.
- Transitions: remit → evidence gathering.
- Unresolved choices: member-generated agenda share; veto rights of commissioning authority.
9. Evidence and submissions
- Purpose: supply the assembly with testimony, documents and stakeholder positions.
- Required actors: evidence-governance bodies (CA UK: Expert Leads + Advisory Panel + Academic Panel — the corpus benchmark, SRC-0038); experts; stakeholders; members requesting evidence.
- Required records: submission register, expert selection rationale, conflict-of-interest disclosures, balance assessment.
- Governance decisions: expert composition; admissibility; member-requested evidence rights.
- Audit/provenance: every piece of evidence needs source, selection rationale and disclosure metadata.
- Privacy: submissions may be personal; anonymity options needed.
- Accessibility/offline: evidence must be usable in accessible formats; oral vs written routes.
- Transitions: evidence → deliberation.
- Unresolved choices: how “balance” is assessed without the gatekeeper becoming the agenda (facilitator/expert capture, SRC-0100).
10. Deliberation
- Purpose: structured member judgement formation.
- Required actors: members; facilitators; secretariat.
- Required records: session structure, facilitation model, deliberative outputs, protected vs public sessions.
- Governance decisions: facilitation method and oversight; what is recorded vs protected (Brussels statutorily protects deliberation, SRC-0030).
- Audit/provenance: facilitation influence is the least auditable stage in the corpus — records must at minimum capture structure, not just outputs.
- Privacy: member contributions may be protected; recording boundaries are a governance decision.
- Accessibility/offline: synchronous/asynchronous/online/offline/hybrid modes all occur in the corpus; interpretation and accessibility support required.
- Transitions: deliberation → recommendation/decision.
- Unresolved choices: degree of session transparency; facilitator influence measurement.
11. Recommendation / decision / dissent
- Purpose: produce the assembly’s formal output.
- Required actors: members (voting/consenting); secretariat recording.
- Required records: question posed, method, eligible electorate, quorum, result, support levels, minority/dissent statements, versioned text.
- Governance decisions: decision method (consensus-seeking + ballot hybrids dominate the corpus); publication of support strengths and minority positions (Leeds tiers; Irish minority reports).
- Audit/provenance: the recommendation text must be preserved exactly as agreed, versioned, and attributable to the assembly — not editable by the receiving authority.
- Privacy: individual votes may be secret while aggregates are public.
- Accessibility: voting must be usable by all members including offline.
- Transitions: recommendation → receiving authority.
- Unresolved choices: unresolved/no-decision states are outputs too and must be representable.
12. Receiving authority
- Purpose: the institution formally obliged (or invited) to receive the output.
- Required actors: receiving institution (parliament, government, council, or none — Assemble has no receiving authority).
- Required records: recipient identity, receipt timestamp, obligation type.
- Governance decisions: who the recipient is; whether a response is owed at all.
- Audit/provenance: receipt of the recommendation must be a recorded event.
- Privacy: none specific.
- Accessibility: none specific.
- Transitions: receipt → formal response (or recorded no-response).
- Unresolved choices: multiple recipients; what happens with no designated recipient.
13. Formal response
- Purpose: the receiving authority’s recorded position on the recommendation.
- Required actors: the receiving authority.
- Required records: response status (accepted / partially accepted / rejected / modified / deferred / no response), reasons, deadline compliance.
- Governance decisions: response deadlines (Scotland’s statutory 6 months, SRC-0043); justified-rejection duties (Ostbelgien, SRC-0021).
- Audit/provenance: the response must be a distinct object from the recommendation — recommendation ≠ response ≠ acceptance ≠ implementation.
- Privacy: none specific.
- Accessibility: public responses should be published accessibly.
- Transitions: response → implementation track or closure.
- Unresolved choices: partial acceptance semantics; who arbitrates disputed rejections.
14. Implementation / rejection / modification
- Purpose: what is actually done — the weakest-evidenced stage in the corpus.
- Required actors: implementing bodies (may differ from the receiving authority).
- Required records: implementation commitments, responsible body, milestones, progress evidence, reasons for delay/rejection.
- Audit/provenance: implementation claims must not be conflated with response text (misleading-implementation-claim risk).
- Privacy: none specific.
- Accessibility: public tracking should be readable without specialist tooling.
- Transitions: tracked over time → follow-up.
- Unresolved choices: who may mark an item implemented; whether tracking implies enforceability (it does not — see
ACCOUNTABILITY.md).
15. Follow-up / accountability
- Purpose: sustained institutional answerability after the response.
- Required actors: receiving/implementing authority; secretariat; the public; former members.
- Required records: periodic review documents, public meetings (Paris droit de suite, SRC-0027), participant follow-up.
- Governance decisions: review cadence; what counts as completion.
- Audit/provenance: the whole chain invitation→selection→output→response→implementation must remain traceable.
- Privacy: member follow-up data retention rules needed.
- Accessibility: follow-up reports public and accessible.
- Transitions: → completion or next cycle.
- Unresolved choices: enforceable vs reputational accountability; who watches the watchers.
16. Completion / rotation / renewal
- Purpose: close a term and, for permanent institutions, renew membership.
- Required actors: secretariat; members; reserves; next cohort.
- Required records: cohort completion, rotation events, institutional memory handoff.
- Governance decisions: rotation fraction (Brussels climate renews by thirds, SRC-0132–0135); carry-over of unfinished work.
- Audit/provenance: rotation draws are selection events — same reproducibility requirements.
- Privacy: end-of-term data retention/deletion rules.
- Accessibility: n/a.
- Transitions: completion → archive; renewal → next invitation/selection cycle.
- Unresolved choices: institutional memory without member incumbency; archive custody.
Sources
research/methods/METHOD-COMPARISON.md,research/theory/THEORY-TO-PRACTICE.md,research/software/CAPABILITY-LANDSCAPE.md- SRC-0017, SRC-0021, SRC-0025, SRC-0027, SRC-0030, SRC-0038, SRC-0043, SRC-0047, SRC-0048, SRC-0073–SRC-0078, SRC-0084, SRC-0100, SRC-0109, SRC-0111, SRC-0118, SRC-0120, SRC-0122, SRC-0132–SRC-0135