Accountability and implementation tracking requirements
CA-R2 requirements record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Implementation tracking is the thinnest stage in the corpus (METHOD-COMPARISON.md reading 4). Best instruments: Paris droit de suite (annual tracking document + public meeting, SRC-0027), Scotland statutory response (SRC-0043), Ostbelgien justified rejection (SRC-0021), Newham standing council commitment (SRC-0047). Tracking does not create legal enforceability — a tracked recommendation is not an implemented one.
Requirements
- Recommendation tracking — each recommendation is a trackable item with a lifecycle, independent of its containing report. Aggregation (all recommendations of cycle X) must be derivable.
- Receiving-authority response — linked to the recommendation, with status per
MANDATE-AND-RESPONSE.md. - Implementation milestones — per commitment: named milestone, target, evidence of progress.
- Responsible body — the implementing body recorded per commitment; may differ from the receiving authority (government responds, agencies implement).
- Progress evidence — published artefacts or attestations linked to milestones; self-report is labelled as such.
- Reasons for delay / rejection — recorded per milestone and commitment, with the actor stating them.
- Public follow-up — tracking surfaces published in accessible form; Paris’s annual public meeting is the corpus’s strongest model (SRC-0027).
- Participant follow-up — members informed of outcomes after service ends (documented as good practice; thin in corpus).
- Periodic review — scheduled review events with their own records (not only ad-hoc updates).
- Completion — explicit terminal state per commitment (done / abandoned / superseded), with evidence.
- Supersession — a commitment replaced by a later decision links to its successor rather than disappearing.
Instruments evidenced in the corpus
| Instrument | Case | Strength |
|---|---|---|
| Statutory response deadline | Scotland (SRC-0043) | binds response only — not delivery |
| Justified rejection | Ostbelgien (SRC-0021) | forces reasoned engagement |
| Droit de suite (annual tracking doc + public meeting) | Paris (SRC-0027) | best sustained-visibility instrument in corpus |
| Standing council commitment | Newham (SRC-0047) | politically revocable |
| Accountability component (Results: % progress, milestones) | Decidim (SRC-0084, SRC-0085) | only reviewed software approximation; manually maintained |
Constraints
- The tracking record must distinguish response, acceptance, commitment, and implementation (see
MANDATE-AND-RESPONSE.md) — a milestone board is not a response. - Whoever maintains tracking is a recorded actor; manual tracking (the corpus norm) must carry maintainer provenance so self-assessment is visible.
- Follow-up must survive the assembly’s own dissolution — accountability obligations outlive one-off bodies (Pattern A).
Open questions
- Who is the tracking custodian when the convening institution no longer exists?
- Whether participant follow-up is owed as a matter of duty or courtesy.
- How implementation evidence is verified without the tracker becoming the judge.
Sources
research/methods/accountability-and-follow-up.md,research/methods/evaluation-methods.md, Paris/Ostbelgien/Scotland/Newham case files,research/software/CAPABILITY-LANDSCAPE.md- SRC-0017, SRC-0021, SRC-0025, SRC-0027, SRC-0030, SRC-0043, SRC-0045, SRC-0047, SRC-0066, SRC-0068, SRC-0084, SRC-0085, SRC-0104, SRC-0109, SRC-0118, SRC-0130