Theory — nested and multi-level assemblies
Updated: 2026-10-05. Stream I (spatial/structural dimension). This compares institutional patterns and trade-offs; it does not design a final model.
Concept
How sortitioned bodies could relate across levels — local, regional, national — and who sits at each level.
Competing patterns
| Pattern | Mechanism | Corpus/literature anchor |
|---|---|---|
| Independent parallel assemblies | each level convenes its own lottery, no membership link | the only pattern actually observed at scale (national assemblies independent of local ones, SRC-0100) |
| Delegates from lower bodies | lower assemblies elect/delegate members upward | Assemble/HotP uses nominated local delegates plus weighted open lottery (SRC-0068); delegate model reintroduces selection by the few |
| Fresh sortition at each level | each level drawn independently from its population | clean equal-probability logic; no corpus instance of deliberate nesting |
| Mixed fresh-sortition + delegation | some seats drawn, some delegated | HotP approximates (open lottery + delegates) (SRC-0068); Legislature-by-Lot literature explores mixed chambers (SRC-0125) |
| Issue-based nesting | nested by remit, not geography | thematic committees feeding a council — Brussels committees are issue-scoped instances (SRC-0030) |
Major theoretical arguments
- Systems view: legitimacy is systemic — lower bodies can feed agenda upward while higher bodies deliberate; roles need not be uniform across levels (SRC-0111, SRC-0112).
- Equality tension: delegation preserves linkage but compresses equal probability (delegates are chosen by a subset); fresh sortition preserves equality but loses institutional linkage — the central nested-systems trade-off (SRC-0109, SRC-0125).
- Scale epistemics: deliberation quality is scale-limited; nesting is one answer to “mass participation vs deliberative depth” (SRC-0106, SRC-0111; see
mass-participation-and-mini-publics.md).
Practical implications
- Any nesting needs defined flows: what travels upward (agendas? members? recommendations?), and what a lower body’s endorsement means upward (SRC-0111).
- Recall/removal and term limits apply differently to delegates (who can recall a delegate?) vs drawn members (removal for non-attendance only?) (open question across corpus).
Critiques / limitations
- No corpus case is a deliberate multi-level sortitioned system — nesting theory is ahead of practice; closest is movement-side HotP (SRC-0068).
- Multi-level designs multiply legitimacy questions: authorisation, mandate and response must be defined per level and between levels.
Operationalisation in the corpus
- Brussels: thematic committees nested under a parliament, not under other sortitioned bodies (SRC-0030).
- Assemble: local assemblies → delegate nominations → national chamber (Claimed mechanism, SRC-0068).
- Everything else: single-level.
Cicada relevance
- For the long-term local/regional/national question, the corpus offers patterns and tensions, not evidence of working multi-level sortition. The trade-off to record: equal probability (fresh draws) vs institutional linkage (delegation). CA-R3/architecture work must not presume a resolution.