Research / theory

Accepted research

Theory — nested and multi-level assemblies

Type: theory Updated: 2026-10-05 Scale: cross-jurisdictional Path: research/theory/nested-and-multi-level-assemblies.md

multi-level

Sources: SRC-0030SRC-0068SRC-0100SRC-0106SRC-0109SRC-0111SRC-0112SRC-0125SRC-0126

Theory — nested and multi-level assemblies

Updated: 2026-10-05. Stream I (spatial/structural dimension). This compares institutional patterns and trade-offs; it does not design a final model.

Concept

How sortitioned bodies could relate across levels — local, regional, national — and who sits at each level.

Competing patterns

PatternMechanismCorpus/literature anchor
Independent parallel assemblieseach level convenes its own lottery, no membership linkthe only pattern actually observed at scale (national assemblies independent of local ones, SRC-0100)
Delegates from lower bodieslower assemblies elect/delegate members upwardAssemble/HotP uses nominated local delegates plus weighted open lottery (SRC-0068); delegate model reintroduces selection by the few
Fresh sortition at each leveleach level drawn independently from its populationclean equal-probability logic; no corpus instance of deliberate nesting
Mixed fresh-sortition + delegationsome seats drawn, some delegatedHotP approximates (open lottery + delegates) (SRC-0068); Legislature-by-Lot literature explores mixed chambers (SRC-0125)
Issue-based nestingnested by remit, not geographythematic committees feeding a council — Brussels committees are issue-scoped instances (SRC-0030)

Major theoretical arguments

Practical implications

Critiques / limitations

Operationalisation in the corpus

Cicada relevance

Sources