Research / theory

Accepted research

Theory to practice — CA-R1 synthesis

Type: theory Updated: 2026-10-05 Scale: cross-jurisdictional Path: research/theory/THEORY-TO-PRACTICE.md

synthesis

Sources: SRC-0017SRC-0021SRC-0027SRC-0030SRC-0031SRC-0032SRC-0038SRC-0043SRC-0044SRC-0047SRC-0078SRC-0079SRC-0100SRC-0101SRC-0106SRC-0109SRC-0111SRC-0118SRC-0119SRC-0120SRC-0121SRC-0122SRC-0123SRC-0125

Theory to practice — CA-R1 synthesis

Updated: 2026-10-05. Central synthesis linking the theory/methods records to the case corpus. Research findings only — no architecture, no policy decisions.

Claims strongly reflected in practice

Claimed principles inconsistently implemented

Where practice conflicts with theory

Design choices that are inherently normative, not technical

  1. Strata selection and weighting (who counts as relevant difference) — SRC-0109.
  2. Attitudinal/political criteria — legitimacy contest.
  3. Invitation weighting (equal raw probability vs corrected representativeness).
  4. Agenda authority (who may place the question).
  5. Response/implementation obligations (what the institution owes).
  6. Transparency vs protection of the deliberative space.
  7. Delegation vs fresh sortition in multi-level designs.

Each of these can be recorded but must not be decided by software defaults — they belong to institutional governance.

Matters that cannot legitimately be delegated to software

Required flags — critical issues

Concepts Cicada must eventually be able to represent explicitly

(Preliminary research synthesis — not a data model.)

Sources