Theory — permanent, recurring and rotating assemblies
Updated: 2026-10-05. Stream I (institutional time dimension). No final model is designed here.
Concept
Sortitioned bodies along a permanence axis: one-off → recurring → permanent standing institution. Plus rotation as the mechanism distributing service over time.
Definitions / competing meanings
- One-off assembly: convened for a single remit, dissolved (CA UK, Scotland, Ireland successive assemblies, SRC-0038, SRC-0043, SRC-0017).
- Recurring assembly: same institution reconvenes periodically (Paris annual promotion + droit de suite, SRC-0025; Newham standing assembly with rotating waves, SRC-0048).
- Permanent citizens’ council: standing body with ongoing functions (Ostbelgien Bürgerrat, 24 members, 18-month rotating terms, SRC-0021).
- Rotation: staggered replacement of membership fractions — preserves continuity while spreading service (SRC-0021).
- Institutional memory: secretariat/rules/precedent carrying knowledge across cohorts — the mechanism that makes permanence work (SRC-0021, SRC-0118).
Major theoretical arguments
- Normative (for permanence): embedding converts ad-hoc input into durable agenda power; OECD identifies institutionalisation routes precisely to solve the “one-off and forgotten” failure (SRC-0118).
- Normative (caution): a permanent selected body can itself become an unaccountable incumbency — rotation, mandate limits and transparency are the controls (SRC-0109, SRC-0111; see
legitimacy-and-accountability.md). - Rotation trade-off: spreads equal-probability service over time and prevents professionalisation, but resets member expertise each cycle — institutional memory must compensate (SRC-0118).
Practical implications
- Permanence requires: standing secretariat, published rules of recurrence, defined agenda competence, and a response route (Ostbelgien decree provides all four, SRC-0021; Brussels rules provide recurrence, SRC-0030).
- Repeat service: whether former members may be redrawn is a fairness/institutional-memory choice; undocumented in most corpus cases (open question).
Critiques / limitations
- Permanent advisory bodies risk capture or ritualisation — response obligations still govern actual impact (SRC-0100).
- Rotation without memory produces restart costs each wave (Newham waves: evidenced but under-evaluated, SRC-0048).
Operationalisation in the corpus
- Permanent by decree: Ostbelgien (SRC-0021); permanent by council commitment: Newham (SRC-0048); permanent by parliamentary rules: Brussels (SRC-0030); recurring with follow-up mechanism: Paris (SRC-0025); one-off: CA UK, Scotland, Leeds (SRC-0038, SRC-0043, SRC-0047).
Cicada relevance
- Permanence is a time-structure property orthogonal to mandate — a permanent advisory body and a one-off co-decision body are different axes. Cicada records should treat permanence, rotation and memory as separate fields.