Case study — Your Party (party-internal sortition and member democracy)
Jurisdiction: United Kingdom (political organisation). Updated: 2026-10-05. Evidence grading follows RESEARCH-METHOD.md. Labels: Observed (official/primary), Claimed (organiser self-description), Evaluation (external/academic), Analysis (Cicada synthesis), Open question.
Neutrality note: this record describes a political party’s internal institutions descriptively. It does not assess political positions, merits or prospects; organisational self-description is labelled Claimed throughout.
1. Identity and jurisdiction
Your Party is a UK political party. This record covers only its documented use of sortition and deliberative mechanisms inside party governance — a party-internal sortition case, structurally different from public-authority assemblies (SRC-0059, SRC-0060, SRC-0061).
2. Dates and legal/institutional basis
Observed: four founding documents — Political Statement, Constitution, Standing Orders, Organisational Strategy — developed through a “founding process” in autumn 2025 and endorsed in all-member votes at a founding conference on 29–30 November 2025 (SRC-0060, SRC-0061). The Members’ Oversight Committee (MOC) was established under the member-approved Organisational Strategy; its first meeting occurred in late January 2026 (Claimed basis: official party page; SRC-0059).
3. Purpose / question-setting
Observed/Claimed: the founding documents were drafted through a multi-channel member process: mass regional assemblies debated drafts in small groups; a crowd-editing tool took direct member edits and approval signals; a “roadmap” process produced evolved drafts, roadmap amendments and individual amendments, with an online all-member priority ballot selecting conference amendments (SRC-0060, SRC-0061). Agenda-setting authority thus sat formally with the membership under standing-orders constraints (e.g. rule that amendments could not accelerate the CEC-election timeline) (SRC-0061).
4. Eligible population
Observed: participation channels were open to party members — an opt-in, self-defined population (membership register), not a civic population sample (SRC-0060, SRC-0061). The MOC was selected from members by lottery (SRC-0059).
5. Invitation frame
Observed: regional assemblies and the crowd-editing tool were open to members (self-selected participation) (SRC-0061). The MOC was drawn from the membership — the published description records random selection conducted by the Sortition Foundation; the sampling frame used (e.g. all members vs volunteers) is not fully specified in public material (Open question) (SRC-0059).
6. Recruitment and sortition method
Observed/Claimed: the five-person MOC was “selected randomly by sortition (lottery), a process conducted by the independent Sortition Foundation” (official party statement — SRC-0059). This is the party’s clearest use of sortition: an oversight body, not a deliberative mini-public. Regional assemblies were open member meetings; conference decisions used one-member-one-vote online ballots (SRC-0061).
7. Stratification criteria
Observed: no public evidence that MOC selection applied stratification targets beyond membership of the party (Open question) (SRC-0059).
8. Size and term
Observed: MOC — five members, time-limited interim role (stewardship period until the elected Central Executive Committee takes office, concluding February 2026) (SRC-0059, SRC-0061). Regional assemblies — event-based, thousands of members reportedly participated (Claimed, SRC-0061).
9. Compensation / accessibility / support
Observed: MOC members described as volunteers; remote/online participation channels used for ballots (SRC-0059, SRC-0061). No payment details published (Open question).
10. Evidence and expert process
Observed/Claimed: the roadmap process used trained facilitators at regional assemblies (small-group notes from 200+ discussions uploaded) and a custom coding/topic-modelling analysis tool built by an in-house programmer to aggregate themes into evolved drafts, with published explainers including graphs and tables (SRC-0061). Claimed novelty (“pioneered by DiEM25” for crowd-editing) is an organisational self-description.
11. Facilitation / deliberation
Observed: regional assemblies used small groups (up to ~10) with trained facilitators; facilitation was party-organised, not independent (SRC-0061).
12. Decision / recommendation method
Observed: member decisions were made by online one-member-one-vote ballots (priority ballot for amendments; all-member votes at conference) — direct member voting, distinct from both sortition and elected-body decision (SRC-0061). The MOC’s role was oversight/tellership, not decision (SRC-0059).
13. Mandate and recipient institution
Observed: the MOC acted as independent tellers overseeing CEC elections during the interim period; Independent Alliance MPs were barred from oversight as candidates (SRC-0059). The elected CEC then took over party management (SRC-0059, SRC-0062).
14. Required response / follow-up
Observed: no external receiving institution — all mechanisms are internal to the party; accountability runs to the membership via ballots and published documents (SRC-0060, SRC-0061).
15. Transparency and participant privacy
Observed: a distinctive privacy stance — MOC members are not compelled to disclose their identities (three consented to be named); rationale: they are not election candidates (SRC-0059). Evolved documents were published with explainers and data on member feedback (SRC-0061).
16. Outcomes / implementation evidence
Observed: founding documents adopted at the November 2025 conference; MOC constituted January 2026 and CEC election oversight proceeded under the stated timeline (SRC-0059, SRC-0061). External evaluation of process integrity is not catalogued (Open question).
17. Critiques / limitations
- Analysis: sortition here serves an electoral-integrity/oversight function inside a membership organisation — categorically different from deliberative mini-publics; Cicada should not collapse these.
- Analysis: member populations are self-selected by joining — sortition of members is not sortition of a civic population.
- Open question: MOC sampling frame, stratification, replacement rules and post-interim institutionalisation of sortition (if any) are not yet fully documented publicly.
18. Software / operational tools
Observed/Claimed: crowd-editing tool (associated with DiEM25 practice), custom analysis/topic-modelling tooling, online ballot platform on the member portal, and a members’ portal for amendments/motions (SRC-0061). Detailed software analysis reserved for the software pass.
19. Sources
- SRC-0059 — Your Party, Members’ Oversight Committee page.
- SRC-0060 — Your Party, Founding documents page.
- SRC-0061 — Your Party, Founding documents: evolutions & amendments page.
- SRC-0062 — Your Party, Organisational Strategy (founding document).
20. Cicada relevance / open questions
- Documents a live, current UK instance of party-internal sortition used for election oversight, alongside mass member deliberation (regional assemblies), crowd-editing and OMOV ballots — a genuinely hybrid internal democracy stack.
- Useful contrast class for modelling: “member” vs “resident/citizen” eligible populations; sortition for oversight vs sortition for deliberation; opt-in assemblies feeding voted outputs.
- Open questions: whether sortition is retained in the standing constitution beyond the interim MOC; stratification/rotation rules; external audit of the lottery.