UK sortition, citizens’ assembly and people’s assembly landscape
Status: CA-R1 research record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Evidence labels per RESEARCH-METHOD.md: Observed (official/primary), Claimed (organiser self-description), Evaluation (external/academic), Analysis (Cicada synthesis), Open question.
Scope: a structured sweep of UK institutional forms — national, devolved and local citizens’ assemblies/juries; party-internal sortition; movement-led national assemblies; and the open people’s-assembly tradition. This is a prioritised sample, not a catalogue of every assembly held in the UK.
1. Terminology and institutional distinctions
UK practice uses overlapping vocabulary. The following distinctions are preserved throughout this corpus rather than collapsed (Analysis, grounded in the cited cases):
| Form | Defining features | UK examples (this corpus) |
|---|---|---|
| Civic-lottery citizens’ assembly | Random postal invitation → opt-in respondents → stratified selection; independent facilitation; learning-deliberation-decision phases | Climate Assembly UK (SRC-0038); Scotland’s Climate Assembly (SRC-0043); Newham (SRC-0048); Devon (SRC-0056); People’s Assembly for Nature (SRC-0057) |
| Citizens’ jury | Same recruitment logic at smaller scale/shorter duration (~20–30 members) | Leeds Climate Change Citizens’ Jury (SRC-0051) |
| Open / self-selected people’s assembly | Anyone may attend; no invitation frame or selection; facilitated structured discussion | XR people’s assemblies (SRC-0068, SRC-0069); Assemble local assemblies (SRC-0063) |
| Open-entry lottery + delegates (movement hybrid) | Applicants self-nominate into a weighted lottery; local assemblies nominate delegates | House of the People (SRC-0064) |
| Party-internal sortition | Lottery used inside a membership organisation for roles (e.g. election oversight); not a civic sample | Your Party MOC (SRC-0059) |
| Hybrid elected + citizen body | Statutory/rules-based mixing of randomly selected citizens and elected members | Brussels deliberative committees (non-UK comparator, brussels-deliberative-committees.md); not yet evidenced in UK public institutions |
| Elected representative structure | Conventional election; included for contrast where it interacts with sortition | Your Party CEC (elected) vs MOC (sortitioned) (SRC-0059) |
| Deliberative consultation | Public input sought (votes, surveys, crowd-editing) without a standing selected body | Newham public topic vote (SRC-0047); People’s Plan for Nature national conversation (~30,000 responses) (SRC-0058); Your Party crowd-editing/priority ballots (SRC-0061) |
Terminology notes: XR’s own manual explicitly warns people’s assemblies “are not to be confused with citizens’ assemblies” (SRC-0068) — a practitioner-endorsed distinction. Assemble brands its weighted open lottery “sortition”; this corpus records that usage without endorsing equivalence to random invitation (SRC-0064). “Permanent” is claimed by both Newham (council decision) and House of the People (self-constituted) — neither has statutory permanence (SRC-0047, SRC-0063).
2. Comparative table — dedicated case records
| Case | Level | Basis | Size | Selection | Mandate / response duty | File |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Climate Assembly UK | UK-wide (six HoC select committees) | Commissioned | 108 | Postal random invitation → stratified (7 criteria incl. climate attitude) | Advisory to committees; BEIS inquiry + govt response (SRC-0039) | climate-assembly-uk.md |
| Scotland’s Climate Assembly | Devolved nation | Statutory (2009 Act s.32A via 2019 Act s.9) | ~106 | Civic lottery, 20,000 household invitations, Sortition Foundation | Advisory; statutory 6-month ministerial response (SRC-0042) | scotland-climate-assembly.md |
| Newham permanent citizens’ assembly | Local authority | Council decision | ~50/cohort, rotating | Civic lottery, 10,000 invitations; half-cohort carry-over | Advisory; standing commitment to formal public response (SRC-0047) | newham-permanent-citizens-assembly.md |
| Leeds Climate Change Citizens’ Jury | City/region | Commissioned by non-statutory Leeds Climate Commission | 25 | Civic lottery, ~4,000 letters | Advisory; council agreed formal response (SRC-0051) | leeds-climate-citizens-jury.md |
| Your Party | Party-internal | Party founding documents | MOC: 5; regional assemblies: open | Sortition of members for oversight role; OMOV ballots | Internal accountability only (SRC-0059) | your-party-institutional-sortition.md |
| Assemble / House of the People | Self-constituted national | None (civil-society) | ~100/sitting | Open-entry weighted lottery + local-assembly delegates | None — claim-making body (SRC-0064) | assemble-house-of-the-people.md |
3. National and devolved coverage (cases without dedicated files)
- Citizens’ Assembly of Scotland (2019–2021): first national citizens’ assembly in Scotland; non-statutory, announced by the First Minister 2019-04-24; 104 members; random household selection across eight parliamentary regions followed by face-to-face recruitment (Mark Diffley Consultancy and Research Ltd); quotas on geography, age, gender, ethnicity, education, limiting long-term conditions/disability and attitudes; suspended by COVID and completed online; output 10 vision statements + 60 recommendations; Scottish Government response published as Doing politics differently (SRC-0045, SRC-0046). Dedicated file created:
citizens-assembly-of-scotland.md— warranted because the non-statutory generalist remit pairs uniquely against the statutory single-issue climate assembly in the same polity. - People’s Assembly for Nature / People’s Plan for Nature (2022–2023): first UK-wide citizens’ assembly commissioned by civil society — RSPB, WWF, National Trust; run by Involve + Sortition Foundation; 103 members (16+, all four nations); 33,000 Royal Mail invitations → registered pool → ~110 selected (SF guidance: ~300 invites per seat); two-stage model where a ~30,000-response national conversation fed the assembly; four weekends (two in-person Birmingham, two online); independent advisory group; plan launched spring 2023 with published partner responses (SRC-0056, SRC-0057, SRC-0058). Architecturally significant: the commissioner-to-respondent chain runs through NGOs, not the state.
- Earlier parliamentary precedent: the House of Commons commissioned a Citizens’ Assembly on Social Care in 2018 (SRC-0038).
- Wales (targeted check, 2026-10-05): qualifying cases found. (i) National Assembly for Wales Citizens’ Assembly (July 2019): first Welsh CA; 60 members; commissioned by the Assembly Commission for the 20th devolution anniversary; delivered by Involve + Sortition Foundation with expert lead Prof. Graham Smith; strata included Welsh-language ability and voter/non-voter status — two strata not seen elsewhere in the UK corpus; remit “how can people in Wales shape their future through the National Assembly”; report presented to the Commission at GWLAD festival (SRC-0137, SRC-0138). (ii) Natural Resources Wales citizens’ assembly (early 2023, ~50 members, natural-environment vision) — recorded via the Welsh Government evidence review (SRC-0139). (iii) The Welsh Government’s commissioned Evidence Review: Mainstreaming participatory and deliberative democracy in Wales (2026) documents emerging institutionalisation and recommends a national participation strategy (SRC-0139). Wales is therefore a live devolved jurisdiction, not an absence — full case file deferred; the 2019 assembly is the strongest candidate.
- Northern Ireland (targeted check, 2026-10-05): no state-commissioned devolved assembly found; significant non-state and utility-led instances exist. (i) Citizens’ Assembly for Northern Ireland (Oct–Nov 2018): civil-society pilot, 75 members, two weekends, social care for older people; ran during the Stormont suspension — the commissioning vacuum is itself institutionally significant (SRC-0140). (ii) SONI Mid Antrim Citizen Sounding Board (2022): 25 members, Sortition Foundation two-stage civic lottery (5,000 invitations, 80/20 deprivation weighting, £180 payment) for an electricity-grid operator — a utility-infrastructure mini-public (SRC-0142). (iii) Initiative for Civic Space Citizens’ Panel (2019, Involve) on citizen voice in NI decision-making (SRC-0143). (iv) Academic evidence on mini-public legitimacy in consociational NI: publics support recommendation-making assemblies more than decision-making ones; elites oppose decision power — directly relevant to mandate design in divided polities (SRC-0141). Constraint note: consociational power-sharing makes binding delegation to a civic body a different legitimacy problem than elsewhere in the UK (Analysis, SRC-0141).
4. Local-authority coverage beyond dedicated files
A wider tier of council-commissioned climate assemblies existed in 2019–2021; two retained in the comparison for institutional variety:
- Camden (July 2019): the UK’s first council citizens’ assembly on the climate crisis; >50 randomly selected residents; three sessions; 17 actions agreed (all ≥75% support); informed the Camden Climate Action Plan; proposals additionally informed by 600+ community ideas; independent UCL evaluation published (SRC-0054).
- Oxford (Sep–Oct 2019): first city-council citizens’ assembly on climate; 50 residents recruited by Ipsos MORI (commercial fieldwork recruitment, not practitioner civic lottery); two weekends; question on earlier-than-2050 net zero (SRC-0055).
- Devon (Jun–Jul 2021): county-level; 70 residents; 14,000-letter postal civic lottery (Sortition Foundation); delivered by Involve after open tender; 11 online sessions (~25h); topics drawn from public consultation on the Interim Devon Carbon Plan; the Devon Climate Emergency partnership (all Devon LAs) responded to each recommendation (SRC-0056).
Analysis: local cases differ mainly on commissioner type (council vs non-statutory commission vs partnership of LAs), recruitment delivery (practitioner lottery vs commercial recruitment) and response commitment (standing vs one-off). No UK local case in this sample carries a statutory response duty.
5. The open people’s-assembly tradition
Observed (practitioner documentation): XR’s People’s Assemblies Manual defines a people’s assembly as a structured, facilitated process in which anyone may choose to take part — “self selected” — and explicitly distinguishes it from citizens’ assemblies “composed of people randomly selected from the population by the process of Sortition” (SRC-0068). Method: three pillars (radical inclusivity, active listening, trust); three phases (set-up/input, deliberation in facilitated breakouts, integration/feedback); hand signals for equal voice; trained facilitators; designed for short, repeatable community use (SRC-0068, SRC-0069).
Analysis: open assemblies maximise access and legitimacy-by-participation but cannot claim population representativeness; selection effects are unmeasured. They function as agenda-generating and community-building infrastructure — which is exactly how Assemble uses them upstream of a weighted lottery chamber (section 6).
6. Movement-led and hybrid models
Assemble / House of the People (dedicated file: assemble-house-of-the-people.md): open local assemblies (Community Charters) + nominated delegates + open-entry weighted lottery (~100 members, first sitting July 2025) → People’s Charter; aspirationally permanent; no receiving authority (SRC-0063, SRC-0064, SRC-0065, SRC-0067). This is the only UK model in the corpus combining three selection channels (open participation, nomination, weighted lottery).
Your Party (dedicated file: your-party-institutional-sortition.md): sortition used for a five-member election-oversight committee (MOC, run by the Sortition Foundation) inside a member democracy stack of regional assemblies, crowd-editing, online priority ballots and an elected CEC (SRC-0059, SRC-0060, SRC-0061). Recorded descriptively; no assessment of the organisation’s politics is made or implied.
7. Practitioner infrastructure
Two organisations supply most of the documented UK delivery capacity — see research/organisations/:
- Sortition Foundation — not-for-profit democratic-lottery specialist; >200 lotteries delivered; two-step method (lottery invitation → lottery selection); OpenDLP platform; open-source stratified-selection code; offices in the UK, Australia, US and Hungary; also campaigns (e.g. replacing the Lords with a House of Citizens). Documented delivery includes Climate Assembly UK, Scotland’s Climate Assembly, Newham, Devon, People’s Assembly for Nature, Leeds (design) and the Your Party MOC (SRC-0038, SRC-0040, SRC-0043, SRC-0051, SRC-0056, SRC-0057, SRC-0059, SRC-0070).
- Involve — independent charity (founded 2003; offices London/Belfast); the UK’s leading public-participation practitioner; designs/delivers assemblies and publishes standards work (e.g. “when is a citizens’ assembly not a citizens’ assembly”); documented delivery includes Climate Assembly UK (facilitation/member liaison), Devon, People’s Plan for Nature, Newham, Westminster (SRC-0038, SRC-0050, SRC-0056, SRC-0058, SRC-0071, SRC-0072).
- Shared Future CIC — practitioner that designed/facilitated the Leeds jury (SRC-0051); dedicated record deferred (material but narrower UK-landscape contribution).
8. Scale and inter-level relationships
Observed/Analysis: UK evidence shows activity at neighbourhood (open assemblies), council (Newham, Camden, Oxford), city-region (Leeds), county (Devon), devolved-nation (Scotland), UK-wide (Climate Assembly UK, People’s Assembly for Nature) and self-constituted national (House of the People) levels. Only Assemble’s model asserts an institutional relationship between levels (local charters → delegates → national chamber) — and it is self-constituted, not a public hierarchy (SRC-0063). Public-authority cases are disconnected one-offs; Newham is the only standing local institution evidenced. No UK statutory framework links levels (Analysis; contrast Ostbelgien’s integrated permanent system, ostbelgien-permanent-citizens-dialogue.md).
9. Principal evidence gaps
Wales and Northern Ireland national/devolved assemblies— resolved 2026-10-05: Wales has a commissioned Senedd citizens’ assembly (2019), an NRW assembly (2023) and a government evidence review (2026); NI has civil-society and utility-led instances plus consociational-context legitimacy research, but no state-commissioned case (see §3).- Mandatory-response and implementation tracking: only Scotland’s Climate Assembly has a statutory duty; recommendation-level uptake is untracked almost everywhere.
- Payment/accessibility detail published unevenly (strong for CA UK; partial for Scotland; thin elsewhere).
- Selection auditability: CA UK open-sourced code; most other draws publish method but not verifiable artefacts.
- Your Party: MOC sampling frame/stratification/rotation post-interim undocumented publicly.
- Assemble/House of the People: lottery pool sizes, weighting algorithm, delegate nomination counts, governance between sittings undocumented; scale figures are self-reported.
- Independent evaluations catalogued only for Camden (UCL) and Scotland’s Climate Assembly (government research report); absent or not yet retrieved for CA UK, Newham, Leeds, Devon, PPFN.
10. Implications and open questions for Cicada
Preliminary research synthesis — not an architecture decision. The evidence suggests Cicada representations may eventually need to distinguish:
| Candidate concept | Observed warrant | Candidate layer (preliminary) |
|---|---|---|
| Eligible population | 16+ residents; exclusions (politicians, party staff); party-membership populations (CA UK SRC-0038; Your Party SRC-0059) | shared foundation (population/eligibility rules) |
| Invitation population | Randomly drawn households (PAF, National Register analogues) (SRC-0038, SRC-0043) | shared foundation |
| Respondents / opt-in pool | 1,748 respondents at 5.8%; ~500 Newham registrants; open lottery applicants (SRC-0038, SRC-0048, SRC-0064) | shared foundation |
| Stratification targets | 7-criteria matrices incl. attitudinal strata; deprivation-weighted invitation frames (SRC-0038) | assemblies-specific |
| Selected assembly / reserve list | 110 selected / 108 seated; replacement from reserves (SRC-0038) | assemblies-specific |
| Membership and term/rotation | Newham half-cohort carry-over; Ostbelgien thirds; per-sitting service (SRC-0047, SRC-0063) | assemblies-specific |
| Open participants | People’s assemblies, national conversations, topic votes (SRC-0058, SRC-0068) | shared foundation (participation channel) |
| Elected representatives | CEC vs MOC; Brussels MPs in committees (SRC-0059) | shared foundation |
| Facilitators | Independent facilitation as quality standard; professional table facilitators (SRC-0038) | assemblies-specific role |
| Evidence providers | Expert Leads / Advisory / Academic panels (SRC-0038) | assemblies-specific role |
| Proposals / topics | Citizen suggestions, public votes, charters, member amendments (SRC-0047, SRC-0061, SRC-0063) | shared foundation |
| Agendas / question-setting | Commissioner-set vs member-set vs distributed (open-layer) question authority (SRC-0038, SRC-0063) | assemblies-specific |
| Recommendations | Counted, voted outputs w/ thresholds and per-item support (SRC-0038, SRC-0054) | assemblies-specific artefact |
| Decisions | Secret ballot; online secure votes; OMOV ballots (SRC-0038, SRC-0061) | assemblies-specific artefact |
| Dissent / minority records | Scottish assembly dissent positions; CA UK vote shares (SRC-0038, SRC-0044) | assemblies-specific artefact |
| Receiving authorities | Select committees; Ministers; councils; NGO partners; none (SRC-0038, SRC-0042, SRC-0058, SRC-0063) | shared foundation |
| Formal response obligations | Statutory 6-month duty (Scotland); standing council commitment (Newham); none (HotP) (SRC-0042, SRC-0047, SRC-0063) | shared foundation (obligation) + assemblies link |
| Implementation / follow-up records | Droit-de-suite analogue absent in UK; response documents exist (SRC-0039, SRC-0044) | shared foundation |
Research questions carried forward:
- Does the UK sample confirm that “response obligation” and “implementation” must be separate states (strong support: Scotland’s statutory response vs untracked uptake; Leeds response-vs-adoption divergence)?
- Should Cicada represent invitation, application and nomination as distinct selection channels, since all three coexist in the UK sample (civic lottery, HotP open lottery, delegate nomination)?
- Is an attitudinal stratum (e.g. climate concern) a first-class pattern or a special case? CA UK and Leeds both used it.
- How should self-constituted bodies with no receiving authority be represented — minimal mandate fields, or an explicit “claim-making” institution type?
- Party-internal sortition: is the MOC pattern (sortition for oversight rather than deliberation) in scope for Assemblies, or a foundation-level “selection by lot” concept?
- Rotation and continuity (Newham carry-over; Ostbelgien thirds) suggest membership/term must be modelled independently of the assembly event itself.
No final architecture is defined here; these are candidate distinctions for later Cicada requirements work.