Membership and term model
CA-R2 requirements record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Defines the membership concepts Cicada must represent across the institutional patterns in INSTITUTIONAL-PATTERNS.md. Concepts only — no schemas.
Core member concepts
- Selected member — a person chosen under an authorised selection specification, who has accepted. Selection ≠ seating: acceptance is a distinct transition.
- Reserve — a person drawn as a standby under the same specification; may become a member through a declared replacement protocol. Reserves are not members and must not be presented as such.
- Replacement — a reserve (or fresh draw) converted to member under a recorded rule; each replacement carries provenance (trigger, rule applied, timestamp).
- Withdrawal — voluntary member exit; recorded with reason class and effect on composition.
- Removal — involuntary exit under a governance rule (conduct, eligibility loss, safeguarding); requires its own authority and recorded reason — higher evidence bar than withdrawal.
- Term — the bounded service period of a member or cohort.
- Cohort — a named group of members sharing a selection event and term window (Paris “promotions” are annual cohorts, SRC-0027).
- Rotation — scheduled partial renewal (Ostbelgien thirds at 18-month terms, SRC-0021; Brussels climate third-wise annual renewal, SRC-0132–SRC-0134).
- Staggered membership — cohorts overlapping so no single draw ever comprises the whole body; preserves continuity without incumbency.
- Repeat service — whether a person may serve again, in what interval, and across which bodies; a governance parameter. Repeat service is a professionalisation/capture vector (SRC-0118).
- Institutional memory — what the institution retains across cohorts (records, method, staff, unfinished business) vs what refreshes with members. Memory should live in institutions and records, not in members’ indefinite tenure.
- Conflict of interest — declarations required of members (and their handling); analogous to expert disclosures in evidence governance.
- Participation support — the provisions making service practically possible (payment, care, access — see
INCLUSION-ACCESSIBILITY.md); recorded per member as used, not assumed. - Compensation — honoraria/per-diem/expenses are part of membership terms (Brussels €75/day; CA UK £150/weekend, SRC-0038); the rate is a governance parameter.
- Safeguarding — duty of care, harassment protection and conduct rules apply to members, staff and facilitators.
- Accessibility — membership terms must state what accommodations exist and how they are requested.
Membership across institution types
| Concept | Temporary assembly | Permanent council | Recurring local assembly | Hybrid elected/citizen body |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Selected member | whole body, one cohort | rotating fraction | per wave | citizen members only |
| Reserve | cohort-lifetime | continuous | per wave | per topic instance |
| Term | assembly duration | fixed + staggered | wave + possible carry-over | committee instance duration |
| Repeat service | moot | bounded by rules | possible | per rules of host |
| Institutional memory | external (secretariat/report) | internal + designed | council commitment | host parliament |
| Removal | rare, conduct | defined process needed | council process | host’s rules + citizen-member rules |
| Co-existence | n/a | overlapping cohorts | overlapping waves | elected + citizens simultaneously |
Requirements
- Membership must be a statused lifecycle, not a boolean flag: invited → responded → selected → reserve/member → (withdrawn/replaced/removed/completed).
- Every transition must be attributable and timestamped; roster history must be reconstructible at any past date (“who was a member on day X”).
- Replacement rules must be part of the authorised selection specification, not ad hoc.
- The system must represent that a person and a membership differ: one person may hold memberships across bodies/cohorts (subject to repeat-service rules); the person record and the membership record must be separable for privacy.
- Member-facing public profile vs internal record is a governance parameter (Brussels protects deliberation and member identity in process, SRC-0030).
- Compensation/support must be representable as delivered provisions, not merely declared policy.
Open questions
- Whether repeat-service rules live at institution level or cross-institution (one person’s lifetime service limit).
- How removal decisions are governed without creating a dismissal power over the selected.
- How much roster transparency permanent councils require vs protected deliberation.