Software — Loomio
Classification: asynchronous group-governance / deliberation-and-decision tool — discussion threads plus a rich poll/decision toolkit for bounded groups. Updated: 2026-10-05. Evidence labels per RESEARCH-METHOD.md. Fit: unresolved — candidate for later CA-R3 assessment.
Identity
- Project: Loomio — “a collaborative decision-making tool”; product of Loomio Cooperative (worker cooperative, New Zealand).
- Repository: https://github.com/loomio/loomio — Ruby (Rails) + frontend; created 2011-11; active (pushed 2026-10-05); ~2,612 stars, 705 forks (SRC-0089).
- Hosted: loomio.com SaaS; self-hosting supported (SRC-0089, SRC-0090).
Licence and distribution
- Licence: AGPL-3.0 (SRC-0089). Genuinely open source; SaaS is the primary documented deployment model.
Core purpose
- Observed: structured discussion → proposal → outcome for defined groups; the “discussion, proposal, votes, reasons and outcome form a record of how the group reached its decision” — durable decision records are a design goal (SRC-0090).
Selection / sortition
- No capability found in reviewed documentation. Loomio does not perform random selection of participants; membership is by invite/group administration.
Participation and deliberation
- Observed: asynchronous discussion threads; proposals with configurable response options (agree/abstain/disagree/block style positions); poll methods — Proposal, Choose, Score, Allocate (dot-vote), Rank, Time poll, STV election; templates — Sense check, Advice, Consent, Consensus, Gradients of agreement, Majority, Question round; quorum, reminders, anonymous voting, vote-reason requirements, changeable votes while open; outcomes published after close (SRC-0090).
- Analysis: maps closely onto the assembly “deliberation → decision → record” stage for small bounded groups; no facilitation/moderation automation (facilitation remains human).
Identity and privacy
- Observed: invite-based group membership with role/permission model; anonymous voting is a per-poll option; ordinary authentication model (email etc.) — not a public-participation identity/verification system (SRC-0090).
API / export / interoperability
- Observed: API exists (documented in developer materials) and export/report functions are described in the manual; depth requires CA-R3 verification (partially documented).
Deployment evidence
- Widely used by cooperatives, civil-society groups and public bodies for group decision-making; not evidenced as the deliberation layer of a sortitioned assembly in this corpus (Open question).
Limitations / open questions
- No recruitment, eligibility verification, witness/audit or accountability features — it is the middle of the lifecycle only.
- Would need to sit alongside separate lottery + evidence + publication + response tooling.
Sources
- SRC-0089 (repo metadata), SRC-0090 (Loomio user manual: polls, proposal templates, decision records).
CA-R3 pinned assessment
- Pinned source/ref:
loomio/loomio@a8845fb53b7dec75960b57a544662820b20d9ba2; release v3.10.0 (SRC-0148). - Licence: AGPL-3.0.
- Maintenance/deployment: active Rails application; hosted and self-host options.
- Relevant CA-REQ coverage: strong for asynchronous session/discussion records (044–045), decision-method diversity (050–054), reasons/outcomes and bounded group membership; not for selection or formal response.
- API/integration seam: API/export exist; exact stable integration contract should be verified at implementation time.
- Identity/privacy: group membership/roles and optional anonymous polls; not civic eligibility verification.
- Operational burden: medium-high if self-hosted.
- Extension/customisation: source-level application customisation rather than a narrow library.
- Accessibility/offline: asynchronous operation helps timing/access constraints but does not satisfy CA-REQ-071.
- Provisional classification: integrate for between-session/asynchronous assembly work where selected.