Research / software-record

Accepted research

Software capability landscape

Type: software-record Updated: 2026-10-05 Jurisdiction: International Scale: cross-jurisdictional Path: research/software/CAPABILITY-LANDSCAPE.md

softwaresynthesis

Sources: SRC-0038SRC-0049SRC-0067SRC-0073SRC-0074SRC-0076SRC-0077SRC-0078SRC-0080SRC-0082SRC-0083SRC-0084SRC-0086SRC-0087SRC-0088SRC-0089SRC-0090SRC-0091SRC-0092SRC-0094SRC-0095SRC-0096SRC-0098

Software capability landscape

Status: CA-R1 research record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Evidence labels per RESEARCH-METHOD.md. Matrix values: native / partial / plugin-module / external-dependency / not found in reviewed documentation / unclear.

Central question: which parts of the assembly lifecycle already have credible software support, and which are under-served or fragmented? Answers are tied to institutional processes evidenced in research/case-studies/, especially UK-SORTITION-ASSEMBLY-LANDSCAPE.md.

1. What the systems are

SystemClassificationLicenceMaintenance signalPer-system record
OpenDLPCivic-lottery platform + stratified-selection engineApache-2.0Young (repo 2025-07), actively pushed (SRC-0073)opendlp.md
PanelotStratified-selection engine (hosted; leximin-optimal)Unverified licence; described as open-source in publicationsService live; repo not located (SRC-0078–SRC-0080)panelot.md
sortition-algorithms (SF)Stratified-selection libraryOpen source (repo)Active; implements the Nature algorithm family (SRC-0077)covered in opendlp.md/panelot.md
DecidimMulti-purpose civic participation platformAGPL-3.0Very active; large deployments (SRC-0082)decidim.md
CONSUL DEMOCRACYMass civic participation / PB platformAGPL-3.0Active; 250+ deployments claimed (SRC-0086, SRC-0087)consul-democracy.md
LoomioAsynchronous group deliberation/decision toolAGPL-3.0Active (SRC-0089)loomio.md
PolisConsensus / opinion-clustering platformAGPL-3.0Active; public API (SRC-0091–SRC-0094)polis.md
Stanford ODPOnline deliberation/video + automated moderationNot found; hosted research infrastructureLimited alpha (SRC-0095, SRC-0096)stanford-online-deliberation-platform.md
Dembrane EchoConversation capture/analysis/reportingOther/unassertedActive, young (SRC-0098)dembrane-echo.md

2. Lifecycle capability matrix

Lifecycle stageOpenDLPPanelotDecidimCONSULLoomioPolisStanford ODPDembrane Echo
Eligible population definitionpartial (operator-defined targets)partial (quota file)not foundpartial (verified-user rules)not foundnot foundnot foundnot found
Sampling frame / invitation populationexternal dependency (address source outside tool)not foundnot foundnot foundnot foundnot foundnot foundnot found
Invitation generation & distributionpartial/external (docs cover invitation ops; postal handled outside)not foundnot foundnot foundnot foundnot foundnot foundnot found
Respondent registrationnative (registration page, respondent data)not foundpartial (registration + verification)native (registered/verified users)partial (invites)partial (open link)unclearnot found
Stratified selectionnativenativenot found for people (proposal draws only)not foundnot foundnot foundnot foundnot found
Reserve / replacement managementnative (documented replacement runs)not foundnot foundnot foundnot foundnot foundnot foundnot found
Selection audit / reproducibilitypartial (open-source algorithm; seed/witness artefacts not evidenced)native (computed lottery + public draw)native for proposal draws (die-roll seed + witnesses)not foundnot foundnot foundnot foundnot found
Identity / eligibility verificationpartial (operator-managed data)partial (anonymised IDs)plugin/module (verification workflows; e.g. CSAM at Brussels)native (census verification)not foundnot foundunclearnot found
Participant onboardingpartial (“keeping warm” docs)not foundpartialpartialpartialnot foundpartial (briefing mode)not found
Agenda / topic generationnot foundnot foundpartial (admin-configured content; proposals feed)partial (proposals feed process)partial (group-driven)partial (seeded statements + open input)native (convener agenda builder)partial (theme synthesis)
Evidence / submissionsnot foundnot foundnative (proposals, documents, meetings, debates)native (proposals w/ documents)partialpartial (statements)native (balanced briefing materials)partial
Facilitator workflownot foundnot foundpartial (admin/moderation)partial (moderation)partial (facilitator settings)partial (moderation queue)native (automated moderator)native (capture/reporting for facilitators)
Synchronous deliberationnot foundnot foundpartial (meetings registration)not foundnot foundnot foundnative (video + queues)partial (records it)
Asynchronous deliberationnot foundnot foundnative (debates, proposals, comments)native (debates)native (threads + decisions)native (async statements/votes)not foundnot found
Proposals / amendmentsnot foundnot foundnativenativepartial (proposals; amendments via process)partial (statements only)not foundnot found
Consensus / ranking / votingnot foundnot foundnative (supports, votes, budgets)native (supports, votes, PB)native (proposal/consent/consensus/score/rank/STV)native (agree/disagree/pass — analytics, not binding)partial (pre/post questionnaires per Deliberative Polling)not found
Minority / dissent capturenot foundnot foundpartial (comments, vote splits)partialpartial (reasons + gradients)native (opinion groups preserve minority structure)partialpartial
Recommendation publicationnot foundnot foundnative (content publishing)partialpartial (outcome statements)native (public reports)partialnative (reports)
Receiving-authority responsenot foundnot foundpartial (process answers/statuses)partialnot foundnot foundnot foundnot found
Implementation / follow-up / accountabilitynot foundnot foundnative-partial (accountability Results: % progress, milestones, links)partial (proposal tracking)not foundnot foundnot foundnot found
Mass public input around a smaller assemblynot foundnot foundnative (process-level public participation)nativepartialnative (scales to very large N)partial (public DP events)native (in-person capture)
APIs / export / import / interoperabilitypartial (CSV in; API undocumented)partial (CSV in/out)native (GraphQL + CSV)partialpartialnative (public API + exports)not foundunclear

Values reflect reviewed documentation only; “not found” is not a claim of absolute absence.

3. Important overlaps

4. Apparent gaps (carefully qualified)

Within this bounded review, no reviewed system was found covering:

5. The missing connective layer

The documented lifecycle —

population → civic lottery → selected assembly → deliberation →
recommendations → receiving authority → formal response → implementation tracking

— is not supported end-to-end by any reviewed system (Analysis). Instead:

Real assemblies in the corpus assemble this chain with institutional process + glue (Involve liaising members, councils publishing responses manually) — i.e., the connective layer today is practitioner labour, not software (SRC-0038, SRC-0049).

This does not conclude Cicada should build that layer. It records that the gap exists and is currently filled institutionally.

6. Preliminary implications for Cicada

Research synthesis only — not architecture, not adoption.