CA-R3 requirement coverage matrix
Maps CA-R2 CA-REQ requirements against assessed technologies. Updated: 2026-10-05.
States: native · partial · ext (possible via extension) · int (external integration) · no · unknown. Many requirements belong to institutional method or the shared Cicada foundation — they are marked method/foundation and are not forced onto software.
Identity and lifecycle (001–008)
| CA-REQ | OpenDLP | Panelot | sort-alg | Decidim | CONSUL | Loomio | Polis | ODP | Echo | Notes |
|---|
| 001 institution lifecycle | partial | no | no | partial | no | no | no | no | no | assembly-as-space exists (Decidim); population→respondent chain only in OpenDLP |
| 002 transition events | partial | no | no | partial | partial | partial | no | no | partial | audit-grade dual-attribution events: no system |
| 003 population rule | no | no | no | no | census-ish | no | no | no | no | method/foundation — nobody has it as artefact |
| 004 frame + coverage | no | no | no | no | partial | no | no | no | no | method |
| 005 invitation campaign | partial | no | no | no | no | no | no | no | no | OpenDLP tracks respondents; mailing is ops |
| 006 funnel record | partial | no | no | no | no | no | no | no | no | funnel reporting thin everywhere |
| 007 respondent pool | native | unknown | n/a | no | no | no | no | no | no | OpenDLP core object |
| 008 withdrawal/replacement | native | unknown | n/a | no | no | no | no | no | no | OpenDLP replacement runs |
Selection (010–021)
| CA-REQ | OpenDLP | Panelot | sort-alg | Notes |
|---|
| 010 spec-gated run | partial | unknown | n/a | targets exist; spec-as-artefact thin |
| 011 strata/quotas/legal basis | partial | partial | native(input) | engine takes categories; legal-basis field is method |
| 012 attitudinal declaration | partial | unknown | partial | can carry the columns; declaration is governance |
| 013 run+seed+witness record | partial | unknown | partial | run records in DB; witness ceremony not evidenced |
| 014 independent re-run | ext | no | native | library re-runnable; bundle packaging absent |
| 015 re-run ≠ overwrite | method | no | method | governance control |
| 016 invitation weighting | method | unknown | n/a | declared-parameter concept is ours |
| 017 reserves ordering | native | unknown | partial | OpenDLP replacements; ordering rules = spec |
| 018 dedupe | partial | unknown | no | platform-level |
| 019 retention rules | no | unknown | no | gap everywhere |
| 020 no automated person-ranking | method | method | method | prohibition is institutional |
| 021 operator discretion bounded | partial | unknown | n/a | operator picks targets freely |
Membership, agenda, evidence, decision (025–055)
| CA-REQ | Decidim | CONSUL | Loomio | Polis | ODP | Echo | OpenDLP | Notes |
|---|
| 025–032 member lifecycle | no | no | partial | no | no | no | partial | group membership ≠ statused assembly membership |
| 035–039 agenda/remit | partial | partial | partial | no | no | no | no | proposals exist; authorised-agenda object absent |
| 042–043 evidence register | partial | partial | partial | no | no | partial | no | documentation/uploads exist; balance-disclosure absent |
| 044–047 deliberation records | partial | no | native | partial | native | partial | no | Loomio+ODP strongest; Echo capture |
| 050–055 decision+dissent | partial | partial | native-ish | no | partial | no | no | Loomio methods map 051; 053 minority objects absent everywhere |
Mandate, response, accountability (060–066)
| CA-REQ | Decidim | Others | Notes |
|---|
| 060 mandate declared | partial | no | process metadata |
| 061 four separate states | partial | no | accountability tracks results; response object thin |
| 062 receiving authority + deadline | partial | no | manual conventions |
| 063 per-commitment objects | partial | no | Decidim Results nearest; hand-maintained |
| 064 self-report vs verified | partial | no | not distinguished natively |
| 065–066 follow-up | partial | no | periodic review not native |
| CA-REQ | CONSUL | Loomio | Polis | Others | Notes |
|---|
| 070 provisions delivered | no | no | no | no | method — institutions deliver support |
| 071 non-digital route | native(mass) | partial | no | partial | ballot boxes/signature sheets (CONSUL) — mass channel only |
| 072 exclusion events | no | no | no | no | gap |
| 073 support-need privacy | no | no | no | no | gap |
| 080–083 authority/permission | partial | partial | no | no | roles exist; dual-attribution audit absent |
| 084 AI-artefact boundary | no | no | no | Echo flags | no system models it |
| 090–092 multi-level | no | no | no | no | absent corpus-wide |
| 095–097 open-input channels | partial | no | native | partial | Polis/Decidim channels; bias-labelling is our requirement |
Explicit non-coverage
- method (no software applies): 003, 004, 010 (the authorisation act), 015, 016, 020, 021 (discretion boundary), 027, 028, 036, 043, 070, 074
- foundation (shared Cicada): 002 parts, 026 roster-history semantics, 029 person/membership split, 080–083 authority objects
- unserved everywhere: 013 witness packaging, 014 re-run bundle, 019 retention rules, 053 dissent objects, 061–065 response-chain objects, 072 exclusion events, 084 AI boundary, 090–092 nesting
Sources
- Per-system records (
research/software/*), SRC-0144–SRC-0152; requirements per requirements/REQUIREMENTS-CATALOGUE.md.