Operational and resource considerations
CA-R3 record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Dependency/ops comparison. No platforms were installed or benchmarked in this phase — figures marked unknown where credible data was not evidenced.
| System | Runtime | Datastore | Containerisation | Footprint | Maintenance complexity | Upgrade burden | Backup needs | Security patch burden | SaaS dependency | Offline viability |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OpenDLP | Python 3.12+, Flask + Celery | Postgres + Redis | Dockerfile + compose present | unknown (small web app class) | low-med | pre-release churn expected | Postgres dumps | Python dep cadence | optional (SF hosted exists) | selection runs offline-capable; web UI needs host |
| sortition-algorithms | Python 3.x | none | n/a (library) | negligible | low | semver releases | n/a | low | none | fully offline |
| Panelot | n/a (hosted) | n/a | n/a | n/a | none for adopter | n/a | n/a | n/a | total (SF-operated) | none |
| Decidim | Ruby on Rails | Postgres (+Redis/Sidekiq, search) | community images | high (multi-component monolith) | high | major-version cadence to track | full stack | high — large surface | none required | none native |
| CONSUL | Ruby on Rails | Postgres + Redis | installer/Ansible documented | high | high | release cadence 2.6.0 etc. | full stack | high | none required | offline participant channels native; platform itself online |
| Loomio | Rails + Vue | Postgres + Redis | loomio-deploy Docker | medium | medium | v3.10.x cadence | Postgres | medium | optional (loomio.com) | email seam partial |
| Polis | JS services + Python math | Postgres + Redis | docker-compose | medium-high (multi-service) | medium-high | no tagged releases — pin SHA | full stack | medium-high | optional (pol.is) | none |
| Stanford ODP | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | total (Stanford-operated, limited alpha) | none |
| Dembrane Echo | TypeScript | Postgres-class (typical) | deploy config in repo | unknown | medium | v2.x cadence | transcripts+media | medium | optional (dembrane.com) | capture offline-ish; synthesis online |
Notes
- Ops burden ranking (heaviest first): Decidim ≈ CONSUL > Polis > Loomio > OpenDLP > Echo > sortition-algorithms.
- Two fully-hosted-only systems (Panelot, ODP) carry service risk instead of ops risk — availability and terms are not ours.
- Offline member-lifecycle operation is unserved everywhere: no candidate supports a selected-member workflow without connectivity; CONSUL’s offline machinery is mass-input only.
- Backup criticality concentrates on Cicada’s own record store under any composition — it is the canonical layer (Composition D reasoning).