Build versus integrate matrix
CA-R3 record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Provisional capability classification — recommendations, not architecture authority.
| Capability | Existing options | CA-R2 fit | Recommendation | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Population/frame record | none | CA-REQ-003/004 | build (thin) | nobody models eligibility rules or frame coverage as artefacts; small, ours |
| Invitations | ops practice; OpenDLP tracks receipt | CA-REQ-005 | method + thin build | mailing is institutional ops; record layer is ours |
| Respondent management | OpenDLP | CA-REQ-007 | integrate (or build-thin) | OpenDLP’s core object exists |
| Stratified selection | sortition-algorithms, OpenDLP, Panelot | CA-REQ-010–013 | adapt/integrate | published engine; no rebuild case |
| Audit ceremony | Decidim die-roll convention only | CA-REQ-013/014 | build (thin) | the unserved layer; mostly method + small code |
| Reserve/replacement | OpenDLP | CA-REQ-017 | integrate | first-class in OpenDLP |
| Onboarding/support | none | CA-REQ-031, 070–073 | build or method | institutional delivery; record layer ours |
| Agenda/remit | Decidim spaces (different semantics) | CA-REQ-035–039 | build (thin) | authorised-agenda object is ours; public input channels may be external |
| Evidence register | uploads everywhere; governance nowhere | CA-REQ-042/043 | build (thin) | balance/disclosure semantics absent |
| Synchronous deliberation | Stanford ODP (unavailable); generic tools | CA-REQ-044/045 | reference/method | facilitation is practice; ODP not deployable |
| Async deliberation | Loomio | CA-REQ-044/045 | integrate | mature, member-shaped, self-hostable |
| Mass public input | Polis, Decidim, CONSUL | CA-REQ-038, 095/096 | integrate | three credible options; choose one at CA-A1 |
| Decisions/voting | Loomio; Decidim | CA-REQ-050–052 | integrate + thin build | methods exist; record contract is ours |
| Dissent objects | none | CA-REQ-053 | build (thin) | absent corpus-wide |
| Recommendations | proposal text anywhere | CA-REQ-055 | build (thin) | immutability+provenance is ours |
| Receiving-authority response | Decidim accountability (partial) | CA-REQ-061/062 | build (thin) | response objects/deadlines absent elsewhere |
| Implementation tracking | Decidim Results (manual) | CA-REQ-063–065 | build (thin) / integrate-Decidim | nearest existing fit still needs our semantics |
| Offline participation | CONSUL ballot boxes; Loomio email; paper | CA-REQ-071 | integrate + method | no member-lifecycle offline anywhere |
| Provenance/audit spine | none | CA-REQ-002, 080–083 | build | the connective layer — genuinely absent |
| Member lifecycle records | none | CA-REQ-025–030 | build | statused membership is ours |
| Multi-level nesting | none | CA-REQ-090–092 | build (thin) | absent corpus-wide |
| AI-artefact boundary | none | CA-REQ-084 | build (thin) | structural labelling is ours |
Reading
- “Build (thin)” = record/semantics layer, not platforms — these are small in engineering terms but carry the institutional meaning the corpus found missing.
- Integrate where a mature system already owns the interaction surface (deliberation, mass input, selection workflow).
- Nothing in the matrix implies a platform build. The pattern emerging is records + ceremony + seams.