Research / analysis

Current research

CA-R3 — build versus integrate matrix

Type: analysis Updated: 2026-10-05 Scale: cross-jurisdictional Path: technology/BUILD-INTEGRATE-MATRIX.md

technologybuild-or-integrate

Sources: SRC-0144SRC-0145SRC-0156SRC-0146SRC-0147SRC-0148SRC-0149SRC-0150SRC-0152

Build versus integrate matrix

CA-R3 record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Provisional capability classification — recommendations, not architecture authority.

CapabilityExisting optionsCA-R2 fitRecommendationReason
Population/frame recordnoneCA-REQ-003/004build (thin)nobody models eligibility rules or frame coverage as artefacts; small, ours
Invitationsops practice; OpenDLP tracks receiptCA-REQ-005method + thin buildmailing is institutional ops; record layer is ours
Respondent managementOpenDLPCA-REQ-007integrate (or build-thin)OpenDLP’s core object exists
Stratified selectionsortition-algorithms, OpenDLP, PanelotCA-REQ-010–013adapt/integratepublished engine; no rebuild case
Audit ceremonyDecidim die-roll convention onlyCA-REQ-013/014build (thin)the unserved layer; mostly method + small code
Reserve/replacementOpenDLPCA-REQ-017integratefirst-class in OpenDLP
Onboarding/supportnoneCA-REQ-031, 070–073build or methodinstitutional delivery; record layer ours
Agenda/remitDecidim spaces (different semantics)CA-REQ-035–039build (thin)authorised-agenda object is ours; public input channels may be external
Evidence registeruploads everywhere; governance nowhereCA-REQ-042/043build (thin)balance/disclosure semantics absent
Synchronous deliberationStanford ODP (unavailable); generic toolsCA-REQ-044/045reference/methodfacilitation is practice; ODP not deployable
Async deliberationLoomioCA-REQ-044/045integratemature, member-shaped, self-hostable
Mass public inputPolis, Decidim, CONSULCA-REQ-038, 095/096integratethree credible options; choose one at CA-A1
Decisions/votingLoomio; DecidimCA-REQ-050–052integrate + thin buildmethods exist; record contract is ours
Dissent objectsnoneCA-REQ-053build (thin)absent corpus-wide
Recommendationsproposal text anywhereCA-REQ-055build (thin)immutability+provenance is ours
Receiving-authority responseDecidim accountability (partial)CA-REQ-061/062build (thin)response objects/deadlines absent elsewhere
Implementation trackingDecidim Results (manual)CA-REQ-063–065build (thin) / integrate-Decidimnearest existing fit still needs our semantics
Offline participationCONSUL ballot boxes; Loomio email; paperCA-REQ-071integrate + methodno member-lifecycle offline anywhere
Provenance/audit spinenoneCA-REQ-002, 080–083buildthe connective layer — genuinely absent
Member lifecycle recordsnoneCA-REQ-025–030buildstatused membership is ours
Multi-level nestingnoneCA-REQ-090–092build (thin)absent corpus-wide
AI-artefact boundarynoneCA-REQ-084build (thin)structural labelling is ours

Reading

Sources