Research / analysis

Current research

CA-R3 — lifecycle composition options

Type: analysis Updated: 2026-10-05 Scale: cross-jurisdictional Path: technology/LIFECYCLE-COMPOSITION.md

technologycompositionoptions

Sources: SRC-0144SRC-0146SRC-0147SRC-0148SRC-0149SRC-0150

Lifecycle composition options

CA-R3 record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Candidate ways the CA-R2 lifecycle could be satisfied by composing Cicada with existing systems. No composition is chosen here — selection belongs to CA-A1 + operator decision.

Composition A — Cicada lifecycle + OpenDLP + external deliberation tools

Cicada owns population/frame/spec/audit + post-selection records; OpenDLP runs the respondent→selection→replacement workflow; Loomio (or similar) covers async member deliberation; mass input via Polis/Decidim.

Composition B — Cicada lifecycle + Decidim participation/accountability + external selection

Decidim carries the public participation envelope (proposals, meetings, results tracking); selection engine consumed directly (sortition-algorithms) or via OpenDLP.

Composition C — mostly-integrated external stack, thin Cicada coordination

Cicada = coordination/provenance ledger recording references into external systems that do the actual work.

Composition D — Cicada-native lifecycle records + optional adapters to external tools

Cicada implements the full record model (population→response tracking) as first-class data; external tools attach via seams as channels (a Polis conversation, a Loomio group, an OpenDLP run) rather than system-of-record.

Composition E — minimal Cicada record/audit layer; process mostly offline/manual

Cicada records specs, runs, rosters, decisions, responses as signed artefacts; institutions execute via paper/email/whatever tools they already use.

Comparative summary

ABCDE
CA-R2 coveragemedmedlowhighlow-med
Build surfacemedmedlowhighlowest
Vendor couplingmedhighextremelownone
Data fragmentationmedhighworstlown/a
Auditabilitymedmedpoorhighmed
Offline viabilitymedlowlowmedn/a
Portabilitymedlowworsthighhigh
Ops burdenmedhighlowmedlow

CA-A1 questions this frames

Sources