Licence assessment
CA-R3 record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Not legal advice — flags obligations and questions for later review.
| Project | Licence | Source evidence | Reuse | Modify | Redistribute | Network/SaaS use | Uncertainty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OpenDLP | Apache-2.0 | repo metadata (SRC-0144) | free | free + notice | free | free — no copyleft-on-network | none material; its dependency sortition-algorithms is GPL-3.0 — the engine boundary inside OpenDLP is GPL-shaped |
| sortition-algorithms | GPL-3.0 | repo + PyPI (SRC-0145) | free | must GPL | must GPL source | network use not triggered (GPL not AGPL) | wrapping as a separate process/service is the usual containment — needs CA-A1 confirmation |
| stratification-app | GPL-3.0 | repo (SRC-0156) | free | must GPL | must GPL | same as above | GUI app — reference more than dependency |
| groupselect-app / -lib | GPL-3.0 / MIT | repo (SRC-0156) | free | per licence | per licence | per licence | role of groupselect vs opendlp path unclear — flag |
| Panelot | unasserted | org listing shows no public repo (SRC-0152) | n/a | n/a | n/a | hosted service only | unresolved — do not assume open source |
| Decidim | AGPL-3.0 | repo (SRC-0146) | free | must AGPL | must AGPL | network use triggers source-sharing for modifications | Cicada-hosted modifications of Decidim would need AGPL publication — relevant to deployment posture |
| CONSUL | AGPL-3.0 | repo + installer (SRC-0147) | free | must AGPL | must AGPL | same AGPL network clause | same |
| Loomio | AGPL-3.0 | repo + loomio-deploy (SRC-0148) | free | must AGPL | must AGPL | same | same |
| Polis | AGPL-3.0 | repo (SRC-0149) | free | must AGPL | must AGPL | same | no tagged releases complicates pinning (edge branch) |
| Stanford ODP | none public | SRC-0154 | n/a | n/a | n/a | hosted alpha | source not public — no licence path |
| Dembrane Echo | BSL (MariaDB) | LICENSE text (SRC-0150) | production only if Total Finances ≤ €1M/12mo | per BSL | per BSL | cap applies | resolves prior uncertainty — not open source today; converts to GPL-2.0+ on Change Date; verify Cicada/org budget position |
Flags for later review
- GPL-3.0 engine boundary: if Cicada wraps sortition-algorithms, keep it a separable component/process — do not link into a combined proprietary work. Architecture consequence for CA-A1.
- AGPL gravity: Decidim/CONSUL/Loomio/Polis are all AGPL — self-hosting unmodified is fine; modified hosted deployments create publication obligations. Integration-over-modification reduces exposure.
- BSL €1M cap on Echo: organisations above the ceiling cannot use it in production — verify before any pilot consideration.
- Panelot: unasserted licence; hosted-only → treat as service, not software.
- Our own output: CA-R3 makes no licensing commitment for Cicada code; that decision is open.