Research / requirement

Current research

Requirements — CA-R2 requirements catalogue

Type: requirement Updated: 2026-10-05 Scale: cross-jurisdictional Path: requirements/REQUIREMENTS-CATALOGUE.md

requirementscatalogue

Sources: SRC-0017SRC-0021SRC-0027SRC-0030SRC-0038SRC-0043SRC-0047SRC-0068SRC-0073SRC-0078SRC-0084SRC-0088SRC-0100SRC-0109SRC-0111SRC-0118SRC-0120SRC-0122SRC-0132

CA-R2 requirements catalogue

Stable identifiers for CA-R2 requirements. Updated: 2026-10-05. Requirements are institutionally testable but not implementation-specific — none prescribe technologies, schemas or APIs.

Priority classes: foundational (every model) · model-dependent (required when the institution adopts the pattern) · optional (pattern-available) · unresolved (requirement exists, shape undecided).

Boundary: shared = shared Cicada foundation candidate · assemblies = Assemblies-specific · external = integration candidate at CA-R3 · method = institutional method only · see BOUNDARY-MAP.md.

Identity and lifecycle

IDRequirementRationaleEvidencePatternsPriorityBoundary
CA-REQ-001The system must represent an assembly as an institution with a declared lifecycle — population through completion/renewal — not as an eventlifecycle is the unit of institutional accountabilitySRC-0021, SRC-0027, SRC-0118allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-002Every lifecycle stage transition must be a recorded, timestamped, attributable eventprovenance is reconstructible state, not log linesSRC-0111allfoundationalshared
CA-REQ-003The system must represent an eligible-population rule as a versioned governance artefact with recorded authorityeligibility is a legitimacy boundarySRC-0030, SRC-0021allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-004The system must record the sampling/invitation frame, its type and its coverage gapframes are a known bias source; coverage gaps must be disclosedSRC-0120, SRC-0021all sortedfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-005The system must record invitation campaigns: population, method, weighting, datesinvitation is the first selection actSRC-0038, SRC-0047all sortedfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-006The system must record the invitation→registration→selection→seating funnelself-selection distortion must be visible, not hiddenSRC-0120, SRC-0038all sortedfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-007The system must represent respondent pools distinctly from frames and membersconflating them misstates representativenessSRC-0106, SRC-0120all sortedfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-008Withdrawal, replacement and completion must be representable stage transitions with reason classessilent exits corrupt composition recordsSRC-0073, SRC-0074all sortedfoundationalassemblies

Selection

IDRequirementRationaleEvidencePatternsPriorityBoundary
CA-REQ-010Selection must execute only against a versioned, authorised selection specificationseparates governance decision from technical executionSRC-0109, SRC-0078all sortedfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-011The specification must record strata, quotas, weights, permitted data fields and their legal basisstrata are legitimacy-contested governanceSRC-0109, SRC-0032, SRC-0122all sortedfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-012Attitudinal/special-category criteria must be explicitly declared or prohibited per specification with legal basisCA UK vs Brussels pole; cannot be an implicit parameterSRC-0038, SRC-0031, SRC-0032all sortedfoundationalmethod+assemblies
CA-REQ-013A selection run must record algorithm identifier, parameters, entropy/seed artefact, witness record and outputreproducibility is the selection-audit standardSRC-0078–SRC-0080, SRC-0083all sortedfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-014Given specification + seed + input-pool digest, an independent party must be able to re-run and verify the resultpublished results must be checkable without operator cooperationSRC-0078, SRC-0080all sortedfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-015Re-running a published selection must never silently replace the published resultaudit ≠ overwriteSRC-0123all sortedfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-016Invitation weighting (e.g. deprivation) must be a declared parameter, not a silent featureequal-invitation-chance is the default claim; exceptions are governanceSRC-0038, SRC-0120all sortedfoundationalmethod
CA-REQ-017Reserves must be produced under the specification with declared ordering/exhaustion rulesreserves are a replacement-time manipulation surfaceSRC-0073, SRC-0074all sortedfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-018Duplicate participation must be preventable across pool, reserves and seated membershipgaming and double-seating riskcorpus methodsall sortedfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-019Respondent/reserve data must have declared retention rules distinct from member datapeople who never served hold the most sensitive silent dataSRC-0122all sortedfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-020No automated/AI system may choose, rank, filter or weight persons for selectionCA-D003, CA-D007 boundaryCA-D003/D007allfoundationalmethod
CA-REQ-021Operator discretion in selection must be representable only inside the specificationoperators must not be able to choose membersSRC-0109all sortedfoundationalmethod

Membership and terms

IDRequirementRationaleEvidencePatternsPriorityBoundary
CA-REQ-025Membership must be a statused lifecycle (invited→responded→selected→reserve/member→withdrawn/replaced/removed/completed), not a flagroster history must be reconstructible at any past dateSRC-0021, SRC-0027allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-026Cohorts, terms, rotation fractions and staggered membership must be representablepermanent institutions are rotating institutionsSRC-0021, SRC-0132–SRC-0134B, C, Dmodel-dependentassemblies
CA-REQ-027Repeat-service rules must be declarable per institutionprofessionalisation controlSRC-0118B, C, Fmodel-dependentmethod
CA-REQ-028Removal requires recorded authority and reason, with a higher evidence bar than withdrawaldismissal power over the selected is dangerouscorpusallfoundationalmethod
CA-REQ-029A person record and a membership record must be separableprivacy; multi-body serviceSRC-0122allfoundationalshared
CA-REQ-030Member public profile vs internal record must be a governance parameterBrussels protected-deliberation modelSRC-0030allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-031Compensation and support provisions must be recorded as delivered per membersupport = representativeness infrastructureSRC-0038, SRC-0101allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-032Conflict-of-interest declarations for members must be representablecorpus-analogous to expert disclosureSRC-0038allfoundationalassemblies

Agenda and remit

IDRequirementRationaleEvidencePatternsPriorityBoundary
CA-REQ-035An assembly’s agenda must consist of authorised items each recording proposer, approver, scope, wording and provenanceagenda-setting is the least-studied consequential powerSRC-0070, SRC-0100allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-036Agenda authority must be a declared property of the institution modelpublic vote vs council vs commissioner are different institutionsSRC-0048, SRC-0021, SRC-0038allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-037Rejected agenda proposals must carry recorded exclusion reasonsexclusion without reasons is an accountability holeSRC-0070allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-038Public agenda input (petitions, topic votes) must be a distinct channel with its own eligibility rules and bias labelmass input is not the agenda authority unless declaredSRC-0048, SRC-0027C, E, Gmodel-dependentassemblies
CA-REQ-039Member rights to propose items or request evidence must be representable where the model grants themmember agency inside a remitSRC-0038, SRC-0044allfoundationalassemblies

Evidence and deliberation

IDRequirementRationaleEvidencePatternsPriorityBoundary
CA-REQ-042An evidence register must record items, sources, selection rationale and conflict-of-interest disclosuresexpert/evidence capture is a documented riskSRC-0038, SRC-0100allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-043Evidence balance assessment must be a recorded human judgement with named assessor and review pathbalance is contestable governance, not algorithmSRC-0100, SRC-0129allfoundationalmethod
CA-REQ-044Session records must capture structure (agenda segment, facilitation model, modality, breakout composition)facilitation is the least auditable stageSRC-0106, SRC-0115allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-045In-person, synchronous-online, asynchronous and hybrid participation must be representable per session/membercorpus includes all modalitiesSRC-0044, SRC-0045allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-046Protected vs publishable deliberation must be an explicit governance declaration per institutionBrussels statutory protection vs transparency poleSRC-0030allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-047Moderation interventions must be recordable in aggregate with actor and authoritymoderation is accountable powerSRC-0106allfoundationalassemblies

Decision and dissent

IDRequirementRationaleEvidencePatternsPriorityBoundary
CA-REQ-050Every decision event must preserve question wording, method, eligible electorate, quorum, result, dissent, provenance and versionthe decision record contractSRC-0017, SRC-0038, SRC-0047allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-051Consensus, consent, majority, supermajority, ranking, score, secret and open voting must all be representable as method parametersno method is mandated; methods are governanceSRC-0116, SRC-0089allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-052Per-recommendation support levels must be publishablestrength-of-support is inconsistently recorded corpus-wide; fix by constructionSRC-0047, SRC-0017allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-053Minority/dissent statements must be first-class outputs linked to the resultsuppression of dissent is a risk classSRC-0017, SRC-0111allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-054An unresolved/no-decision outcome must be a representable terminal stateforced closure falsifies the recordcorpusallfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-055Recommendation text must be immutable post-closure; the receiving authority cannot edit itrecommendation ≠ responseSRC-0043allfoundationalassemblies

Mandate, response and accountability

IDRequirementRationaleEvidencePatternsPriorityBoundary
CA-REQ-060Mandate type (consultation…delegated…legislative) must be declared per institution/cycle before it runsmandate is institutional fact, not inferredSRC-0021, SRC-0043allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-061Recommendation, response, acceptance and implementation must be four separate recorded statesthe corpus’s main accountability failure is conflationSRC-0027, SRC-0043allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-062A receiving authority and response obligation (incl. deadline) must be declarable; no response and overdue are visible statessilence must be recordable, not a nullSRC-0043, SRC-0021allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-063Responses must decompose into per-commitment objects with responsible body, milestones, evidence, delay/rejection reasonstracking binds commitments, not sentimentsSRC-0027, SRC-0084allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-064Implementation evidence must distinguish self-report from independent verificationmisleading implementation claims are a risk classSRC-0027allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-065Follow-up must be schedulable as periodic review events (e.g. droit de suite class) and survive assembly dissolutionaccountability outlives one-off bodiesSRC-0027, SRC-0047A, B, Cfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-066Participant follow-up must be representablemembers see outcomes; thin in corpusSRC-0101alloptionalassemblies

Inclusion and accessibility

IDRequirementRationaleEvidencePatternsPriorityBoundary
CA-REQ-070Payment, expenses, travel, caring, disability, interpretation, literacy support must be representable as per-member provisionsseating ≠ participationSRC-0038, SRC-0101allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-071Every required member interaction must have a non-digital route (postal/telephone/in-person)digital exclusion is structuralSRC-0088, SRC-0120allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-072Exclusion events — a selected person unable to participate for want of provision — must be recordablerepresentativeness loss must be visibleSRC-0101allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-073Support needs are voluntary declarations; the need is not a public factprivacy of accommodationsSRC-0122allfoundationalassemblies
CA-REQ-074Member protection from targeting, lobbying and harassment must be a declared institution propertymembers become public-interest targetsSRC-0030, SRC-0101allfoundationalmethod

Authority versus permission

IDRequirementRationaleEvidencePatternsPriorityBoundary
CA-REQ-080Every consequential action must record both the acting account and the institutional authority invokeddual attribution makes authority gaps visibleSRC-0100, SRC-0106allfoundationalshared
CA-REQ-081Authorisations (selection specs, remits, agenda approvals, response obligations) must be recorded artefacts with provenanceauthority must exist as an object before it is exercisedSRC-0109allfoundationalshared
CA-REQ-082Actions whose actor lacked recorded authority must be representable and flaggablesoftware flags divergence; institutions adjudicatecorpusallfoundationalshared
CA-REQ-083Technical access must never confer institutional authority; superuser actions on consequential objects must be audit-visible eventsno constitutional power by backdoorcorpusallfoundationalshared
CA-REQ-084AI-generated artefacts must be structurally distinguishable from authoritative records and advisory onlyCA-D007; authority laundering riskCA-D007allfoundationalshared

Multi-level and nested structures

IDRequirementRationaleEvidencePatternsPriorityBoundary
CA-REQ-090Nesting/delegation relationships between assemblies must be explicitly representable — including nonemodels 1–5 are structurally different institutionsSRC-0125multi-levelmodel-dependentassemblies
CA-REQ-091Delegation events and fresh sortition draws must be distinct auditable event classesdifferent legitimacy mechanismsSRC-0111, SRC-0125multi-levelmodel-dependentassemblies
CA-REQ-092Descriptive-representativeness claims must not be silently composed upward — a delegated body is not population-representativelegitimacy fraud by compositionSRC-0125multi-levelfoundationalassemblies

Open-participation and mass input

IDRequirementRationaleEvidencePatternsPriorityBoundary
CA-REQ-095Open/self-selected participation must be representable with a distinct legitimacy basis — never rendered as sortitionmisleading-representativeness riskSRC-0066, SRC-0106E, Gmodel-dependentassemblies
CA-REQ-096Mass input feeding an assembly must be a separate population channel carrying its own bias profilemass channel ≠ membershipSRC-0092, SRC-0106Gmodel-dependentassemblies
CA-REQ-097Organisational populations (e.g. party membership) must be representable as framesPattern F internal sortitionSRC-0059–SRC-0062Fmodel-dependentassemblies

Catalogue totals

Sources

All requirement records under requirements/; research/methods/METHOD-COMPARISON.md; research/theory/THEORY-TO-PRACTICE.md; research/software/CAPABILITY-LANDSCAPE.md; SRC-0017–SRC-0143 corpus.