CA-R2 requirements catalogue
Stable identifiers for CA-R2 requirements. Updated: 2026-10-05. Requirements are institutionally testable but not implementation-specific — none prescribe technologies, schemas or APIs.
Priority classes: foundational (every model) · model-dependent (required when the institution adopts the pattern) · optional (pattern-available) · unresolved (requirement exists, shape undecided).
Boundary: shared = shared Cicada foundation candidate · assemblies = Assemblies-specific · external = integration candidate at CA-R3 · method = institutional method only · see BOUNDARY-MAP.md.
Identity and lifecycle
| ID | Requirement | Rationale | Evidence | Patterns | Priority | Boundary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CA-REQ-001 | The system must represent an assembly as an institution with a declared lifecycle — population through completion/renewal — not as an event | lifecycle is the unit of institutional accountability | SRC-0021, SRC-0027, SRC-0118 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-002 | Every lifecycle stage transition must be a recorded, timestamped, attributable event | provenance is reconstructible state, not log lines | SRC-0111 | all | foundational | shared |
| CA-REQ-003 | The system must represent an eligible-population rule as a versioned governance artefact with recorded authority | eligibility is a legitimacy boundary | SRC-0030, SRC-0021 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-004 | The system must record the sampling/invitation frame, its type and its coverage gap | frames are a known bias source; coverage gaps must be disclosed | SRC-0120, SRC-0021 | all sorted | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-005 | The system must record invitation campaigns: population, method, weighting, dates | invitation is the first selection act | SRC-0038, SRC-0047 | all sorted | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-006 | The system must record the invitation→registration→selection→seating funnel | self-selection distortion must be visible, not hidden | SRC-0120, SRC-0038 | all sorted | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-007 | The system must represent respondent pools distinctly from frames and members | conflating them misstates representativeness | SRC-0106, SRC-0120 | all sorted | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-008 | Withdrawal, replacement and completion must be representable stage transitions with reason classes | silent exits corrupt composition records | SRC-0073, SRC-0074 | all sorted | foundational | assemblies |
Selection
| ID | Requirement | Rationale | Evidence | Patterns | Priority | Boundary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CA-REQ-010 | Selection must execute only against a versioned, authorised selection specification | separates governance decision from technical execution | SRC-0109, SRC-0078 | all sorted | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-011 | The specification must record strata, quotas, weights, permitted data fields and their legal basis | strata are legitimacy-contested governance | SRC-0109, SRC-0032, SRC-0122 | all sorted | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-012 | Attitudinal/special-category criteria must be explicitly declared or prohibited per specification with legal basis | CA UK vs Brussels pole; cannot be an implicit parameter | SRC-0038, SRC-0031, SRC-0032 | all sorted | foundational | method+assemblies |
| CA-REQ-013 | A selection run must record algorithm identifier, parameters, entropy/seed artefact, witness record and output | reproducibility is the selection-audit standard | SRC-0078–SRC-0080, SRC-0083 | all sorted | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-014 | Given specification + seed + input-pool digest, an independent party must be able to re-run and verify the result | published results must be checkable without operator cooperation | SRC-0078, SRC-0080 | all sorted | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-015 | Re-running a published selection must never silently replace the published result | audit ≠ overwrite | SRC-0123 | all sorted | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-016 | Invitation weighting (e.g. deprivation) must be a declared parameter, not a silent feature | equal-invitation-chance is the default claim; exceptions are governance | SRC-0038, SRC-0120 | all sorted | foundational | method |
| CA-REQ-017 | Reserves must be produced under the specification with declared ordering/exhaustion rules | reserves are a replacement-time manipulation surface | SRC-0073, SRC-0074 | all sorted | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-018 | Duplicate participation must be preventable across pool, reserves and seated membership | gaming and double-seating risk | corpus methods | all sorted | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-019 | Respondent/reserve data must have declared retention rules distinct from member data | people who never served hold the most sensitive silent data | SRC-0122 | all sorted | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-020 | No automated/AI system may choose, rank, filter or weight persons for selection | CA-D003, CA-D007 boundary | CA-D003/D007 | all | foundational | method |
| CA-REQ-021 | Operator discretion in selection must be representable only inside the specification | operators must not be able to choose members | SRC-0109 | all sorted | foundational | method |
Membership and terms
| ID | Requirement | Rationale | Evidence | Patterns | Priority | Boundary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CA-REQ-025 | Membership must be a statused lifecycle (invited→responded→selected→reserve/member→withdrawn/replaced/removed/completed), not a flag | roster history must be reconstructible at any past date | SRC-0021, SRC-0027 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-026 | Cohorts, terms, rotation fractions and staggered membership must be representable | permanent institutions are rotating institutions | SRC-0021, SRC-0132–SRC-0134 | B, C, D | model-dependent | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-027 | Repeat-service rules must be declarable per institution | professionalisation control | SRC-0118 | B, C, F | model-dependent | method |
| CA-REQ-028 | Removal requires recorded authority and reason, with a higher evidence bar than withdrawal | dismissal power over the selected is dangerous | corpus | all | foundational | method |
| CA-REQ-029 | A person record and a membership record must be separable | privacy; multi-body service | SRC-0122 | all | foundational | shared |
| CA-REQ-030 | Member public profile vs internal record must be a governance parameter | Brussels protected-deliberation model | SRC-0030 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-031 | Compensation and support provisions must be recorded as delivered per member | support = representativeness infrastructure | SRC-0038, SRC-0101 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-032 | Conflict-of-interest declarations for members must be representable | corpus-analogous to expert disclosure | SRC-0038 | all | foundational | assemblies |
Agenda and remit
| ID | Requirement | Rationale | Evidence | Patterns | Priority | Boundary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CA-REQ-035 | An assembly’s agenda must consist of authorised items each recording proposer, approver, scope, wording and provenance | agenda-setting is the least-studied consequential power | SRC-0070, SRC-0100 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-036 | Agenda authority must be a declared property of the institution model | public vote vs council vs commissioner are different institutions | SRC-0048, SRC-0021, SRC-0038 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-037 | Rejected agenda proposals must carry recorded exclusion reasons | exclusion without reasons is an accountability hole | SRC-0070 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-038 | Public agenda input (petitions, topic votes) must be a distinct channel with its own eligibility rules and bias label | mass input is not the agenda authority unless declared | SRC-0048, SRC-0027 | C, E, G | model-dependent | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-039 | Member rights to propose items or request evidence must be representable where the model grants them | member agency inside a remit | SRC-0038, SRC-0044 | all | foundational | assemblies |
Evidence and deliberation
| ID | Requirement | Rationale | Evidence | Patterns | Priority | Boundary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CA-REQ-042 | An evidence register must record items, sources, selection rationale and conflict-of-interest disclosures | expert/evidence capture is a documented risk | SRC-0038, SRC-0100 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-043 | Evidence balance assessment must be a recorded human judgement with named assessor and review path | balance is contestable governance, not algorithm | SRC-0100, SRC-0129 | all | foundational | method |
| CA-REQ-044 | Session records must capture structure (agenda segment, facilitation model, modality, breakout composition) | facilitation is the least auditable stage | SRC-0106, SRC-0115 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-045 | In-person, synchronous-online, asynchronous and hybrid participation must be representable per session/member | corpus includes all modalities | SRC-0044, SRC-0045 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-046 | Protected vs publishable deliberation must be an explicit governance declaration per institution | Brussels statutory protection vs transparency pole | SRC-0030 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-047 | Moderation interventions must be recordable in aggregate with actor and authority | moderation is accountable power | SRC-0106 | all | foundational | assemblies |
Decision and dissent
| ID | Requirement | Rationale | Evidence | Patterns | Priority | Boundary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CA-REQ-050 | Every decision event must preserve question wording, method, eligible electorate, quorum, result, dissent, provenance and version | the decision record contract | SRC-0017, SRC-0038, SRC-0047 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-051 | Consensus, consent, majority, supermajority, ranking, score, secret and open voting must all be representable as method parameters | no method is mandated; methods are governance | SRC-0116, SRC-0089 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-052 | Per-recommendation support levels must be publishable | strength-of-support is inconsistently recorded corpus-wide; fix by construction | SRC-0047, SRC-0017 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-053 | Minority/dissent statements must be first-class outputs linked to the result | suppression of dissent is a risk class | SRC-0017, SRC-0111 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-054 | An unresolved/no-decision outcome must be a representable terminal state | forced closure falsifies the record | corpus | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-055 | Recommendation text must be immutable post-closure; the receiving authority cannot edit it | recommendation ≠ response | SRC-0043 | all | foundational | assemblies |
Mandate, response and accountability
| ID | Requirement | Rationale | Evidence | Patterns | Priority | Boundary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CA-REQ-060 | Mandate type (consultation…delegated…legislative) must be declared per institution/cycle before it runs | mandate is institutional fact, not inferred | SRC-0021, SRC-0043 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-061 | Recommendation, response, acceptance and implementation must be four separate recorded states | the corpus’s main accountability failure is conflation | SRC-0027, SRC-0043 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-062 | A receiving authority and response obligation (incl. deadline) must be declarable; no response and overdue are visible states | silence must be recordable, not a null | SRC-0043, SRC-0021 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-063 | Responses must decompose into per-commitment objects with responsible body, milestones, evidence, delay/rejection reasons | tracking binds commitments, not sentiments | SRC-0027, SRC-0084 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-064 | Implementation evidence must distinguish self-report from independent verification | misleading implementation claims are a risk class | SRC-0027 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-065 | Follow-up must be schedulable as periodic review events (e.g. droit de suite class) and survive assembly dissolution | accountability outlives one-off bodies | SRC-0027, SRC-0047 | A, B, C | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-066 | Participant follow-up must be representable | members see outcomes; thin in corpus | SRC-0101 | all | optional | assemblies |
Inclusion and accessibility
| ID | Requirement | Rationale | Evidence | Patterns | Priority | Boundary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CA-REQ-070 | Payment, expenses, travel, caring, disability, interpretation, literacy support must be representable as per-member provisions | seating ≠ participation | SRC-0038, SRC-0101 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-071 | Every required member interaction must have a non-digital route (postal/telephone/in-person) | digital exclusion is structural | SRC-0088, SRC-0120 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-072 | Exclusion events — a selected person unable to participate for want of provision — must be recordable | representativeness loss must be visible | SRC-0101 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-073 | Support needs are voluntary declarations; the need is not a public fact | privacy of accommodations | SRC-0122 | all | foundational | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-074 | Member protection from targeting, lobbying and harassment must be a declared institution property | members become public-interest targets | SRC-0030, SRC-0101 | all | foundational | method |
Authority versus permission
| ID | Requirement | Rationale | Evidence | Patterns | Priority | Boundary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CA-REQ-080 | Every consequential action must record both the acting account and the institutional authority invoked | dual attribution makes authority gaps visible | SRC-0100, SRC-0106 | all | foundational | shared |
| CA-REQ-081 | Authorisations (selection specs, remits, agenda approvals, response obligations) must be recorded artefacts with provenance | authority must exist as an object before it is exercised | SRC-0109 | all | foundational | shared |
| CA-REQ-082 | Actions whose actor lacked recorded authority must be representable and flaggable | software flags divergence; institutions adjudicate | corpus | all | foundational | shared |
| CA-REQ-083 | Technical access must never confer institutional authority; superuser actions on consequential objects must be audit-visible events | no constitutional power by backdoor | corpus | all | foundational | shared |
| CA-REQ-084 | AI-generated artefacts must be structurally distinguishable from authoritative records and advisory only | CA-D007; authority laundering risk | CA-D007 | all | foundational | shared |
Multi-level and nested structures
| ID | Requirement | Rationale | Evidence | Patterns | Priority | Boundary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CA-REQ-090 | Nesting/delegation relationships between assemblies must be explicitly representable — including none | models 1–5 are structurally different institutions | SRC-0125 | multi-level | model-dependent | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-091 | Delegation events and fresh sortition draws must be distinct auditable event classes | different legitimacy mechanisms | SRC-0111, SRC-0125 | multi-level | model-dependent | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-092 | Descriptive-representativeness claims must not be silently composed upward — a delegated body is not population-representative | legitimacy fraud by composition | SRC-0125 | multi-level | foundational | assemblies |
Open-participation and mass input
| ID | Requirement | Rationale | Evidence | Patterns | Priority | Boundary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CA-REQ-095 | Open/self-selected participation must be representable with a distinct legitimacy basis — never rendered as sortition | misleading-representativeness risk | SRC-0066, SRC-0106 | E, G | model-dependent | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-096 | Mass input feeding an assembly must be a separate population channel carrying its own bias profile | mass channel ≠ membership | SRC-0092, SRC-0106 | G | model-dependent | assemblies |
| CA-REQ-097 | Organisational populations (e.g. party membership) must be representable as frames | Pattern F internal sortition | SRC-0059–SRC-0062 | F | model-dependent | assemblies |
Catalogue totals
- 68 stable requirements (CA-REQ-001…097; numbering leaves gaps within each block for future insertion without renumbering)
- foundational: 59 · model-dependent: 8 · optional: 1 · unresolved: 0 (unresolved questions are tracked per-document, not as requirements)
- The catalogue is model-agnostic: it does not choose a constitutional model, an algorithm, or a platform.
Sources
All requirement records under requirements/; research/methods/METHOD-COMPARISON.md; research/theory/THEORY-TO-PRACTICE.md; research/software/CAPABILITY-LANDSCAPE.md; SRC-0017–SRC-0143 corpus.