Research / requirement

Current research

Requirements — multi-level and nested assembly models

Type: requirement Updated: 2026-10-05 Scale: cross-jurisdictional Path: requirements/MULTI-LEVEL-MODELS.md

requirementsmulti-level

Sources: SRC-0021SRC-0030SRC-0068SRC-0100SRC-0106SRC-0109SRC-0111SRC-0112SRC-0125SRC-0126

Multi-level and nested assembly models

CA-R2 requirements record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Compares models for organising assemblies across geographic/institutional levels. Most of this comparison is theoretical — the corpus contains no direct real-world implementation of nested sortition structures. Evidence basis is research/theory/nested-and-multi-level-assemblies.md (SRC-0109, SRC-0111, SRC-0112, SRC-0125, SRC-0126) plus the single-level real cases. No empirical validation is claimed where none exists.

The core recorded trade-off (theory, SRC-0111/SRC-0125): equal probability of selection argues for fresh independent draws at each level; linkage and accountability argue for delegation upward.

Model 1 — Independent sortition at each level

Neighbourhood → local → regional → national assemblies are each selected independently by fresh stratified draws.

Model 2 — Delegation upward

Lower-level assemblies select or delegate members to sit in higher-level bodies.

Model 3 — Mixed delegation + fresh sortition

Some higher-level seats are filled by delegation (continuity), the rest by fresh stratified draws (representativeness).

Model 4 — Permanent upper citizens’ council + temporary issue assemblies

A standing citizens’ council exists at the upper level; it convenes, briefs or oversees temporary single-issue assemblies beneath it (the Ostbelgien relation, generalised — SRC-0021).

Model 5 — Issue-based networks rather than strict geography

Bodies organised around policy domains (climate, housing, care) drawing members across levels rather than per territory.

Comparative summary

ModelRepresentativenessContinuityPower concentrationComplexityEvidence
1 independent drawsstrong per levelnonelowestlow design / high opstheoretical
2 delegation upwardweakeststrongesthighestlow ops / high legitimacytheoretical for sortition
3 mixed delegation + drawmoderatepartialboundedhighest designtheoretical
4 permanent council + issue assembliesgoodhigh in councilconcentrated, rotatedmoderateimplemented (Ostbelgien)
5 issue networkscontestedissue-levelstakeholder capture riskhigh definitionalpartially (issue-scoped cases)

Cicada requirements

Sources