Research / requirement

Current research

Requirements — institutional pattern library

Type: requirement Updated: 2026-10-05 Scale: cross-jurisdictional Path: requirements/INSTITUTIONAL-PATTERNS.md

requirementsinstitutional-models

Sources: SRC-0017SRC-0021SRC-0025SRC-0027SRC-0030SRC-0038SRC-0041SRC-0043SRC-0044SRC-0045SRC-0047SRC-0048SRC-0059SRC-0063SRC-0066SRC-0068SRC-0109SRC-0111SRC-0118SRC-0125SRC-0132

Institutional pattern library

CA-R2 requirements record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Compares the institutional patterns evidenced in the CA-R1 corpus. No preferred constitutional model is chosen — the requirement is that Cicada Assemblies be capable of representing and supporting each pattern without prematurely committing to one.

Pattern A — One-off advisory assembly

Evidence: Ireland (SRC-0017, SRC-0021), Climate Assembly UK (SRC-0038), Scotland’s Climate Assembly (SRC-0041–SRC-0046), Citizens’ Assembly of Scotland (SRC-0044, SRC-0045).

Pattern B — Permanent rotating citizens’ institution

Evidence: Ostbelgien permanent citizens’ council + citizens’ dialogues (SRC-0021, SRC-0025), Paris annual-cohort assembly with droit de suite (SRC-0027), Brussels permanent climate citizens’ assembly (SRC-0132–SRC-0135).

Pattern C — Standing local assembly with recurring cohorts

Evidence: Newham permanent citizens’ assembly (SRC-0047, SRC-0048), Leeds citizens’ jury (SRC-0047 as comparator).

Pattern D — Hybrid elected + sortition institution

Evidence: Brussels deliberative committees — parliamentary rules mix elected MPs with drawn citizens (SRC-0030, SRC-0068).

Pattern E — Open / self-selected people’s assembly

Evidence: Assemble / House of the People (SRC-0063–SRC-0067), XR-style open people’s assembly methodology (SRC-0066).

Pattern F — Party-internal sortition

Evidence: Your Party institutional sortition — sortition used for internal member-democracy functions including election oversight (SRC-0059–SRC-0062).

Pattern G — Mass participation feeding a smaller deliberative body

Evidence: THEORY-TO-PRACTICE mass-input channel finding; Polis-style opinion mapping at scale (SRC-0091–SRC-0094); Decidim/CONSUL public participation channels (SRC-0082–SRC-0088); Newham’s public topic vote (SRC-0048).

Cross-pattern requirements

DimensionA one-offB permanentC standing localD hybridE openF partyG mass+mini
Population/frameyesyesyesyesoptionalmemberstwo populations
Stratified selectionyesyesyesyesnoyesmini only
Rotation/cohortsnoyesyesper topicnorulesno
Agenda authority objectcommissionerself/mixedpublic voteparliamentmovementpartymixed
Response obligationvariableinstitutionalisedcommitmentparliamentarynoneinternalvia host
Receiving authoritycommissionerparliament/councilcouncilchambernoneparty organshost
Implementation trackingthindroit de suite classcommitmentparliamentarynoneinternalvia host

Shared requirement: every pattern must declare — as recorded governance objects, not software defaults — its legitimacy source, selection method, agenda authority, mandate type, response obligation and accountability instrument.

Sources