Method — stratification ethics and governance
Updated: 2026-10-05. Stream D — a priority area. Records competing approaches; does not decide Cicada policy.
Who decides which characteristics count
- Commissioner/organiser choice is the norm: CA UK’s seven strata set by the commissioning consortium with Parliament approval (SRC-0038).
- Rules-based choice: Brussels fixes baseline criteria (gender, age, geography, language, education) in parliamentary rules; topic-linked supplementary criteria are chosen by the Comité d’accompagnement after exchange with the committee — an institutionalised, semi-participatory strata-governance mechanism (SRC-0031).
- Statutory constraint: Brussels prohibits criteria based on GDPR special-category data (arts 9–10) — the corpus’s clearest case where data-protection law removes strata options (SRC-0032, SRC-0122).
Criterion types and their governance profile
| Criterion | Used in corpus | Governance issues |
|---|---|---|
| Geographic | all | low controversy; needed for territorial legitimacy |
| Sex/gender | all | binary categories contested; low controversy as a stratum |
| Age | all | low controversy |
| Socioeconomic/deprivation | CA UK (invitation weighting + education stratum) | proxy choice is political |
| Education | CA UK, Brussels | doubles as class proxy; self-report reliability |
| Ethnicity | CA UK, Scotland | special-category data under GDPR — Brussels prohibition excludes it there (SRC-0032); UK practice allows with consent |
| Disability | not evidenced as a stratum | support needs handled via inclusion, not quota (gap) |
| Political/attitudinal | CA UK climate-attitude stratum; Brussels permits topic-linked “political (e.g. vote/abstention)” criteria subject to limits (SRC-0031) | most contested — see below |
| Behavioural | Brussels permits topic-linked (SRC-0031) | measurement/consent issues |
The core tensions (recorded, not resolved)
- Statistical representativeness vs equal probability: every quota reduces the chance-structure of pure lot; every unstratified draw tolerates achieved imbalance. Leximin methods manage the trade-off within the respondent pool but cannot remove it (SRC-0109, SRC-0078).
- Attitudinal stratification — legitimacy dispute: for (CA UK rationale): prevents a climate-sceptic-free room, mirrors population opinion (SRC-0038). Against: opinions are not demographics — quotas on belief risk engineering the outcome and are manipulable (state the remit, measure attitude, select the answer); self-reported and changeable (SRC-0124 sceptical tradition; contested — no consensus in literature).
- Quotas as politically determinative: because strata + weights decide who is in the room, the design of the strata table is the least-scrutinised consequential decision in the pipeline; Brussels’ rules-based criteria + institutional ratification is the corpus’s best-governed answer (SRC-0031).
- Data protection: special-category strata (ethnicity, health, political opinion, religion) require explicit legal basis/consent — Brussels solves by prohibition, UK by consent-based collection (SRC-0032, SRC-0038, SRC-0122).
- Small-cell privacy: intersecting strata at N≈100 make individuals identifiable — publication of composition should be at marginal level, not cell level (SRC-0122; practice implication).
- Manipulation surface: whoever chooses strata can shape the room — transparency of the choice (published criteria + rationale, per SRC-0101 transparency principle) is the main defence.
Corpus comparators (required)
- Brussels: GDPR special-category prohibition + rules-defined baseline + advisory-body-selected topic criteria = the strictest governed model (SRC-0031, SRC-0032).
- Climate Assembly UK: deprivation-weighted invitation + attitudinal balancing stratum = the most interventionist representativeness engineering in the corpus (SRC-0038).
Cicada relevance
- Strata governance is a recordable institution-level decision: Cicada should represent strata choice, who chose, under what constraint, and publication — not hard-code a strata policy. Whether to permit attitudinal strata is an open governance question, not a software parameter.