Method — consensus, dissent capture and institutional response
Updated: 2026-10-05. How output and uptake are engineered.
Concept
How assemblies convert deliberation into legitimate collective output — and how receiving institutions are bound to respond.
Definitions / competing meanings
- Consensus vs majority rule: consensus-seeking protects minority voice but risks lowest-common-denominator or stalled outputs; majority voting resolves but can overwrite dissent. The corpus shows hybrids: deliberated recommendation + vote threshold (SRC-0044, SRC-0100).
- Minority/dissent capture: formal mechanisms preserving disagreement — minority reports, recorded dissent, support-threshold publication (Leeds’ three recommendation tiers, SRC-0047).
- Recommendation publication: output format affects uptake — a single negotiated report vs multi-tiered graded recommendations.
- Receiving-authority response: procedural obligation to reply — strongest form: statutory deadline (Scotland 6 months, SRC-0043); medium: justified rejection rights (Ostbelgien, SRC-0021); weak: courtesy responses (SRC-0047).
- Implementation tracking: distinct from response — almost entirely absent from the corpus (see
CAPABILITY-LANDSCAPE.md).
Major theoretical arguments
- Normative: consensus is the deliberative ideal but empirically minority voices need structural protection — dissent capture is a legitimacy mechanism, not a failure mode (SRC-0111, SRC-0114).
- Empirical: response obligations are the strongest observed determinant of institutional impact; voluntary responses decay (SRC-0043 vs SRC-0047).
Practical implications
- Design the output contract before deliberation: what form, what threshold, what dissent mechanism (SRC-0101).
- Design the response contract: statutory > convention > goodwill (SRC-0043, SRC-0021, SRC-0047).
Critiques / limitations
- Graded outputs can be ignored selectively — Scotland’s statutory response still left implementation discretion (SRC-0045).
- “Consensus” claims without recorded dissent are unverifiable.
Operationalisation in the corpus
- Leeds: three-tier recommendation strength (unanimous/majority/minority) — explicit dissent preservation (SRC-0047).
- Scotland: statutory 6-month ministerial response + published response document (SRC-0045).
- Ostbelgien: parliament may reject with justification — a bounded veto (SRC-0021).
- XR/HotP: no receiving authority — output legitimacy rests on publicness alone (SRC-0070, SRC-0068).
Cicada relevance
- Output/response contract fields in the case template exist because this is where legitimacy becomes binding — the theory file justifies treating “who must answer” as a structural property.