Method — decision methods
Updated: 2026-10-05. Stream G. Deliberation method and final decision method are distinct stages — consensus-seeking is a process, the vote is a conclusion.
Decision methods observed/available
- Consensus (unanimity): protects minority voice; risks lowest-common-denominator output or minority veto; Ireland’s assemblies used consensus-seeking before falling back to ballots (SRC-0017).
- Consent (no sustained objection): sociocratic variant — objection must be reasoned, not just disliked (Loomio implements as a decision type, SRC-0089; limited corpus institutional use).
- Simple majority: resolves deadlock; overwrites dissent unless dissent is separately recorded.
- Supermajority: raises legitimacy threshold for consequential recommendations; used as hybrid (consensus-seek then ≥2/3 or ≥50% ballot) (SRC-0044).
- Ranking/score/multi-option ballots: better preference expression than binary; STV/ranked/score implemented in tools (SRC-0089) but corpus assemblies mostly use threshold votes.
- Secret vs open ballot: secret protects member independence from peer/lobby pressure; open enables accountability of the record — assemblies typically publish aggregate support, not individual votes (SRC-0047).
- Recommendation thresholds: per-item supermajority/majority for inclusion (SRC-0047 tiers).
- Recording strength of support: publishing unanimity/majority/minority per recommendation — Leeds’ three-tier output is the corpus’s best dissent-preservation mechanism (SRC-0047).
- Minority reports: formal dissent documents (Ireland published minority positions, SRC-0017).
- Non-decision: documented unresolved outcomes are legitimate output — forced consensus is worse than recorded disagreement (SRC-0116 reasoning).
Distinguish process from conclusion
- Deliberation seeks understanding; the decision method closes it. Consensus-seeking as a deliberation norm can coexist with majority rule as the closure rule (SRC-0044, SRC-0100).
- Do not assume consensus is superior: it trades decisiveness for voice protection; the corpus’s strongest outputs pair deliberated drafting with a transparent vote + published support levels (SRC-0047, SRC-0044).
Corpus instances
- Scotland: deliberated recommendations + weighted/ballot conclusion (SRC-0044).
- Ireland: consensus attempt then secret ballots; minority reports published (SRC-0017).
- Leeds: three recommendation-strength tiers (SRC-0047).
- Paris: vœux adopted by consensus or vote; published (SRC-0025).
- Brussels: committee produces recommendations under parliamentary rules (SRC-0030).
Cicada relevance
- Decision method is a configurable, recordable property: closure rule, threshold, ballot secrecy, and dissent-recording are separate fields — conflating “deliberation” with “consensus” is the design error.