Method — mandate, accountability and follow-up
Updated: 2026-10-05. Stream H (methods side). Theory side in research/theory/legitimacy-and-accountability.md.
Mandate taxonomy
| Mandate type | Meaning | Corpus instance |
|---|---|---|
| Advisory | advice, no obligation to respond | Leeds (courtesy responses, SRC-0047) |
| Consultative | formal input, expected consideration | Ireland → Oireachtas debate (SRC-0017) |
| Agenda-setting | power to place items on an institution’s agenda | Ostbelgien council (SRC-0021) |
| Recommendatory | formal recommendations + response obligation | Scotland statutory 6-month response (SRC-0043) |
| Oversight | monitoring/scrutiny role | Your Party MOC (electoral oversight, SRC-0066) |
| Veto/rejection rights | institution may reject only with justification | Ostbelgien justified-rejection (SRC-0021) |
| Co-decision | recommendations enter decision machinery | Brussels committees feed parliamentary work (SRC-0030) |
| Self-mandating | body authorises itself | Assemble/HotP (SRC-0068) |
Response vs adoption vs implementation (required distinctions)
- Response: the receiving institution replies — weakest binding level. Scotland’s statutory 6-month response is the strongest response duty in the corpus (SRC-0043, SRC-0045).
- Adoption: the institution accepts recommendations as policy intent — Paris commits to respond and track via droit de suite annual document + public meeting (SRC-0025, SRC-0027).
- Implementation: actual delivery — systematically weakest: even statutory response leaves delivery discretion (SRC-0045); Decidim’s accountability module tracks progress % but no corpus case shows legal implementation enforcement (SRC-0085).
What legitimises authority exercised by a random body (required question)
Synthesis: legitimacy is composite and staged — representativeness (who sits) + deliberation quality (how they reason) + legal/institutional mandate (who authorised) + public authorisation (statute/elected delegation). No single component sufficed in any corpus case; the strongest chains combine statutory mandate + transparent lottery + protected deliberation + mandatory response (SRC-0043 vs SRC-0068 contrast). Lafont’s caveat stands: descriptive resemblance alone authorises nothing (SRC-0104).
Can a standing random council become unaccountable?
Yes — structurally: no election, fixed members, accumulated agenda power. Controls observed/theorised: rotation (SRC-0021), published rationale, transparency of method, bounded mandate (recommend only), and a stronger body’s response duty. The accountability of a permanent sortitioned body is institutional design, not electoral (SRC-0118, SRC-0109).
What happens when recommendations are ignored
- Statutory response still permits substantive rejection (SRC-0045) — the obligation is to answer, not to adopt.
- Ignored recommendations without response obligation → reliance on publicity/political pressure (SRC-0047, SRC-0068).
- Implementation tracking mechanisms: Paris droit de suite document+meeting (SRC-0027), platform progress-tracking (SRC-0085) — partial, not enforcement.
Cicada relevance
- Mandate type, response obligation, and tracking mechanism are separate recordable fields; the corpus’s core finding is that response ≠ adoption ≠ implementation and only the first is ever formally obligated.