Method comparison — cross-case matrix
Updated: 2026-10-05. Maps documented methods across corpus cases. unknown/not yet evidenced = not established in current records, not asserted absent. Case files hold the underlying evidence; source IDs below point to register entries.
| Method dimension | Ireland | Ostbelgien | Paris | Brussels | Climate Assembly UK | Scotland | Newham | Assemble (HotP) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basis | commissioned by Oireachtas | permanent by decree (2019) | city institution w/ annual cohorts | permanent parliamentary rules | commissioned by 6 select committees | statutory duty | standing council commitment | self-constituted movement |
| Sampling frame | contracted quota 2016-18 → postal household lottery 2019+ | population register | electoral lists + voluntary registration | population register | Royal Mail address database, 30,000 invited | civic lottery (postal) | local civic lottery | open entry (self-nomination) + nominated local delegates |
| Invitation method | postal (later model); earlier contracted recruiter | register draw | draw + registration | register draw | postal letters, deprivation-weighted | postal civic lottery | postal/digital invite | application + weighted lottery |
| Response pool | funnel documented in case file | register → opt-in | unknown/not yet evidenced | register draw | ~7% response; educated skew → overweighting | documented funnel | funnel in case file | self-described pool |
| Stratification | gender/age/geography/class | age, gender, language, region | criteria per promotion | gender, age, geography, language, education + topic-linked (no GDPR special-category) | gender, age, ethnicity, geography, urban/rural, education + climate attitude; +5 seats | statutory representativeness; strata incl. attitudes | strata refreshed per wave | weighting self-described |
| Selection engine/tool | secretariat/recruiter | unknown/not yet evidenced | bailiff-supervised draw (PV published) | draw under decree | open-source stratified selection code | unknown/not yet evidenced | unknown/not yet evidenced | internal |
| Payment/support | expenses + support | compensation documented at practice level | vouchers/compensation (per case file) | documented | £150/weekend + care + accessibility | payment + support | honorarium reported | volunteer movement basis |
| Agenda authority | Oireachtas resolution | selected citizens’ council sets jury agendas | council grants requests + member proposals + petitions | parliamentary committees + citizen membership | commissioner committees | statute | public topic vote | movement/charter |
| Evidence governance | expert + stakeholder + public submissions via secretariat | secretariat-supported | documented per topic | under parliamentary rules | expert leads + advisory panel + academic panel | structured evidence programme + research evaluation | practitioner-organised | movement-curated |
| Facilitation | professional | professional (secretariat continuity) | organised | professional; protected deliberation statutory | consortium professional | professional | practitioner | people’s-assembly method (open) |
| Decision method | consensus-seek → secret ballots; minority reports | recommendations under decree | vœux by consensus or vote | committee recommendations | deliberated + votes | deliberated + ballot | recommendations | consensus-style + charter |
| Dissent capture | minority reports | under decree | published vœux | committee records | vote publication | published | report | unknown/not yet evidenced |
| Response obligation | parliamentary debate | parliament may reject only with justification | droit de suite: annual tracking doc + public meeting | committee reports to chamber | government response (provided; non-statutory) | statutory 6-month ministerial response | standing council response commitment | none — no receiving authority |
| Implementation tracking | referendum/policy record | secretariat continuity | annual follow-up document + meeting | parliamentary follow-up | weak | published response; delivery discretionary | council commitment | n/a |
| Permanence/rotation | successive one-offs | permanent rotating council (24 members, 18-month terms) | annual cohorts (promotions) | permanent rules-based recurrence | one-off | one-off | standing assembly, rotating waves | intended permanent chamber |
Readings
- Response obligation is the strongest differentiator: statutory (Scotland) > justified-rejection (Ostbelgien) > published tracking (Paris droit de suite) > standing commitment (Newham) > courtesy (Leeds) > none (Assemble).
- Agenda authority varies most: public vote (Newham), selected council (Ostbelgien), statute (Scotland), commissioners (CA UK), movement (Assemble).
- GDPR special-category strata prohibition (Brussels, SRC-0032) vs attitudinal stratification (CA UK, SRC-0038) are the corpus’s two poles of strata governance.
- Implementation tracking is thin everywhere: even the best (Paris droit de suite, Scotland statutory response) bind response, not delivery.
- Frames trend postal/register-based; open-entry (Assemble) is the outlier — participation, not statistical selection.