Research / method

Accepted research

Method comparison — cross-case matrix

Type: method Updated: 2026-10-05 Scale: cross-jurisdictional Path: research/methods/METHOD-COMPARISON.md

Sources: SRC-0017SRC-0021SRC-0025SRC-0027SRC-0030SRC-0032SRC-0038SRC-0043SRC-0045SRC-0048SRC-0066SRC-0068

Method comparison — cross-case matrix

Updated: 2026-10-05. Maps documented methods across corpus cases. unknown/not yet evidenced = not established in current records, not asserted absent. Case files hold the underlying evidence; source IDs below point to register entries.

Method dimensionIrelandOstbelgienParisBrusselsClimate Assembly UKScotlandNewhamAssemble (HotP)
Basiscommissioned by Oireachtaspermanent by decree (2019)city institution w/ annual cohortspermanent parliamentary rulescommissioned by 6 select committeesstatutory dutystanding council commitmentself-constituted movement
Sampling framecontracted quota 2016-18 → postal household lottery 2019+population registerelectoral lists + voluntary registrationpopulation registerRoyal Mail address database, 30,000 invitedcivic lottery (postal)local civic lotteryopen entry (self-nomination) + nominated local delegates
Invitation methodpostal (later model); earlier contracted recruiterregister drawdraw + registrationregister drawpostal letters, deprivation-weightedpostal civic lotterypostal/digital inviteapplication + weighted lottery
Response poolfunnel documented in case fileregister → opt-inunknown/not yet evidencedregister draw~7% response; educated skew → overweightingdocumented funnelfunnel in case fileself-described pool
Stratificationgender/age/geography/classage, gender, language, regioncriteria per promotiongender, age, geography, language, education + topic-linked (no GDPR special-category)gender, age, ethnicity, geography, urban/rural, education + climate attitude; +5 seatsstatutory representativeness; strata incl. attitudesstrata refreshed per waveweighting self-described
Selection engine/toolsecretariat/recruiterunknown/not yet evidencedbailiff-supervised draw (PV published)draw under decreeopen-source stratified selection codeunknown/not yet evidencedunknown/not yet evidencedinternal
Payment/supportexpenses + supportcompensation documented at practice levelvouchers/compensation (per case file)documented£150/weekend + care + accessibilitypayment + supporthonorarium reportedvolunteer movement basis
Agenda authorityOireachtas resolutionselected citizens’ council sets jury agendascouncil grants requests + member proposals + petitionsparliamentary committees + citizen membershipcommissioner committeesstatutepublic topic votemovement/charter
Evidence governanceexpert + stakeholder + public submissions via secretariatsecretariat-supporteddocumented per topicunder parliamentary rulesexpert leads + advisory panel + academic panelstructured evidence programme + research evaluationpractitioner-organisedmovement-curated
Facilitationprofessionalprofessional (secretariat continuity)organisedprofessional; protected deliberation statutoryconsortium professionalprofessionalpractitionerpeople’s-assembly method (open)
Decision methodconsensus-seek → secret ballots; minority reportsrecommendations under decreevœux by consensus or votecommittee recommendationsdeliberated + votesdeliberated + ballotrecommendationsconsensus-style + charter
Dissent captureminority reportsunder decreepublished vœuxcommittee recordsvote publicationpublishedreportunknown/not yet evidenced
Response obligationparliamentary debateparliament may reject only with justificationdroit de suite: annual tracking doc + public meetingcommittee reports to chambergovernment response (provided; non-statutory)statutory 6-month ministerial responsestanding council response commitmentnone — no receiving authority
Implementation trackingreferendum/policy recordsecretariat continuityannual follow-up document + meetingparliamentary follow-upweakpublished response; delivery discretionarycouncil commitmentn/a
Permanence/rotationsuccessive one-offspermanent rotating council (24 members, 18-month terms)annual cohorts (promotions)permanent rules-based recurrenceone-offone-offstanding assembly, rotating wavesintended permanent chamber

Readings

  1. Response obligation is the strongest differentiator: statutory (Scotland) > justified-rejection (Ostbelgien) > published tracking (Paris droit de suite) > standing commitment (Newham) > courtesy (Leeds) > none (Assemble).
  2. Agenda authority varies most: public vote (Newham), selected council (Ostbelgien), statute (Scotland), commissioners (CA UK), movement (Assemble).
  3. GDPR special-category strata prohibition (Brussels, SRC-0032) vs attitudinal stratification (CA UK, SRC-0038) are the corpus’s two poles of strata governance.
  4. Implementation tracking is thin everywhere: even the best (Paris droit de suite, Scotland statutory response) bind response, not delivery.
  5. Frames trend postal/register-based; open-entry (Assemble) is the outlier — participation, not statistical selection.

Sources