Method — evidence and expert governance
Updated: 2026-10-05. Stream F (evidence component).
Concept
Who decides what the assembly learns, from whom, and how contested claims are balanced — the upstream power that shapes “informed” judgement.
Method elements
- Expert selection: CA UK’s three-tier model — expert leads (content), advisory panel (balance), academic panel (rigour) — the corpus’s most governed evidence structure (SRC-0038). Selection of experts is agenda power.
- Stakeholder evidence: invited submissions balance formal expert input; managed, not raw, intake (SRC-0102, SRC-0017).
- Participant-requested evidence: members request further witnesses/data — a documented check on the expert frame (SRC-0038, SRC-0129).
- Evidence challenges/adversarial balance: competing witnesses + cross-questioning (CA UK committee-stage adversarial presentations, SRC-0038).
- Conflicts of interest: disclosed affiliations of witnesses; corpus records vary (gap on systematic disclosure).
- Source transparency: published evidence packs + witness lists — CA UK publishes; elsewhere uneven (SRC-0038).
- Misinformation handling: facilitation/expert response to contested factual claims; KNOCA evidence guidance stresses quality/diversity/accessibility of evidence (SRC-0129).
- Evidence packs/time limits: curated reading with bounded volume — accessibility constraint on evidence depth (SRC-0129).
Governance question
The evidence layer is where commissioner influence is least visible: choosing which questions get evidence, which experts appear, and what counts as contested (SRC-0102). Transparency mechanisms: published expert-governance structure (SRC-0038), advisory balance review, member evidence requests.
Corpus instances
- CA UK: three-tier governance + adversarial committee stage (SRC-0038).
- Ireland: expert + stakeholder + public submissions to secretariat (SRC-0017).
- Ostbelgien: council/jury receives information via secretariat; expert involvement documented less formally (SRC-0021).
- Scotland: structured evidence programme + research report evaluation (SRC-0044).
- Brussels: committee work under parliamentary rules with protected deliberation (SRC-0030).
Cicada relevance
- Evidence governance is recordable structure: who selected, what disclosed, how challenged. Cicada records should capture evidence-governance architecture, not just “evidence was provided”.