Research / method

Accepted research

Method — evaluating assemblies and deliberative processes

Type: method Updated: 2026-10-05 Scale: cross-jurisdictional Path: research/methods/evaluation-methods.md

deliberationevaluation

Sources: SRC-0017SRC-0027SRC-0038SRC-0040SRC-0044SRC-0045SRC-0047SRC-0100SRC-0101SRC-0102SRC-0106SRC-0114SRC-0117SRC-0119SRC-0120SRC-0123SRC-0127SRC-0129SRC-0132SRC-0136SRC-0137

Method — evaluating assemblies and deliberative processes

Updated: 2026-10-05. Task E. Warranted: the corpus contains evaluated cases (Scotland research reports, CA UK inquiry) plus an OECD evaluation framework (SRC-0119) and KNOCA impact framework (SRC-0136).

Frames

Input evaluation

Process evaluation

Output evaluation

Outcome evaluation

Evaluation independence

ModelPropertiesCorpus instance
Commissioner-runfast, resourced; conflicts obviousScottish Government research reports — official evaluation of own process (SRC-0044, SRC-0045)
External academicindependent, methodologically stronger; slowerHansard Society external critique at Senedd 2019 CA (SRC-0137); Fournier et al comparative evaluations (SRC-0127)
Practitioner self-evaluationinsider knowledge; self-interest riskorganiser reports common across corpus
Participant surveys/mixedmember experience captures inclusionScotland CA research report (SRC-0044)
Conflict flag: designers evaluating own processes is common — KNOCA/OECD independence framing applies (SRC-0119, SRC-0136).

Comparative closeout — evaluation evidence in the corpus

Cicada relevance

Sources