State machines
CA-A1 architecture record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Explicit allowed/invalid transitions for the canonical objects. Every transition records: actor · institutional authority · timestamp · reason · provenance. An invalid transition is rejected at the record layer — it cannot be written; an attempted write outside the machine produces a flagged divergence event (see AUTHORITY-MODEL), never a silent correction.
Assembly lifecycle (CA-OBJ-003, cycle state)
draft → authorised → recruiting → selected → active → completed → follow-up → closed
| Transition | Authority | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| draft→authorised | establishment/commission authority | remit may still be pending for member-set-agenda models |
| authorised→recruiting | operational (delegated admin) | invitation campaign opens |
| recruiting→selected | witnessed SelectionRun ref | only via sealed run — never manual |
| selected→active | seating authority | onboarding complete for quorum cohort |
| active→completed | declared conclusion rule (sessions done / report adopted) | |
| completed→follow-up | response obligation active | obligations outlive the cycle |
| follow-up→closed | review authority | obligations discharged, lapsed or declared abandoned |
Exceptional transitions: authorised→closed (cycle cancelled before recruiting — requires authority + reason); recruiting→authorised (recruitment suspended, e.g. funding); any→closed on institutional dissolution (Brussels evidence: permanence-by-ordonnance can stall). Invalid: recruiting→active (skipping witnessed selection); closed→* (terminal); backwards moves (corrections are new versions/events).
Selection specification (CA-OBJ-008)
draft → review → authorised → locked → executed → retired/superseded
| Transition | Authority | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| draft→review | spec editor submits | |
| review→authorised | authorising instrument ref | the governance act — required before any run |
| authorised→locked | ceremony opens | lock precedes run; prevents modification |
| locked→executed | witnessed run completes | |
| *→superseded | authorising instrument | new version authorised; old preserved |
| *→retired | authorising instrument | withdrawn without replacement |
Invalid: any edit to authorised/locked/executed content — amendments are new versions; executed→draft; unauthorised review→authorised. A spec must never be edited silently after authorisation — version chain only.
Membership lifecycle (CA-OBJ-012)
Defined in MEMBERSHIP-LIFECYCLE.md; state set:
invited → responded → eligible / ineligible → selected → seated → completed
↑ ↓ ↓
│ reserve withdrawn / removed
└──────────────────────┘ replaced
eligible→selectedandreserve→seatedrequire witnessed-run/replacement event + authority — never manual.removedrequires elevated authority + reason + evidence (highest bar).completed,withdrawn,removed,replacedare terminal for that membership.- Invalid:
invited→seated,responded→selected(no eligibility step), any transition without the run/authority event the machine requires.
Recommendation lifecycle (CA-OBJ-021 + 020)
draft → deliberating → closed → published → responded → implementation-tracking
draft→deliberating: session linkage begins.deliberating→closed: decision event completes the question. Closed text is immutable — corrections are new versioned recommendations citing the prior.closed→published: publication act per transparency model.published→responded: response object received (orno-responsedeclaration at deadline).responded→implementation-tracking: commitments exist to track.
Invalid: edit of closed text; closed→draft; responded without a Response object.
Response lifecycle (CA-OBJ-025)
pending → submitted → accepted / partially-accepted / rejected / modified / deferred → implementation-tracking
└── overdue (derived) → no-response (declared state)
overdueis computed, not a transition — deadline passed withstatus=pending.no-responseis a declared record — the institution records the silence; absence of a response object at deadline does not erase the obligation.rejected/modified/deferredrequirejustification— bare rejection is malformed.accepted/partially-acceptedspawn ImplementationCommitments;rejectedcloses the obligation with reason;deferredcarries a new deadline.
Invalid: pending→accepted (no submitted response); deletion of a no-response record; back-dating received_at.
Invariant summary
| Object | Terminal states | Immutability point |
|---|---|---|
| Cycle | closed | closure archives the cycle record |
| Spec | retired / superseded | content frozen at authorised |
| Membership | completed / withdrawn / removed / replaced | transition history append-only |
| Recommendation | implementation-tracking (lifecycle continues on response chain) | text at closed |
| Response | implementation-tracking / closed-out | response text at submitted |