Audit and provenance model
CA-A1 architecture record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Append-only historical reconstruction is the semantic contract. Storage implementation is deliberately undecided.
Event record shape
Every consequential event records:
event_idtimestampactor— account/credentialauthority_ref— AuthorityArtefact invoked (or explicitnone, where the act needs none, e.g. respondent reply)object_ref— what was changedprevious_state/new_statereasonevidence_ref— supporting artefactsoftware_component+version— which system recorded it (Cicada vs external seam)external_system_ref— where the act physically happened in an external tooldigest— content hash where the object is a document/artefact
Consequential events (non-exhaustive)
- spec authorised/locked/superseded; run executed; bundle sealed; verification re-run
- membership transitions (all)
- remit/agenda versions; evidence admissions/contestations
- session open/close; record sealing
- decision closure; recommendation adoption; dissent filing
- response receipt; commitment/milestone state changes; follow-up reviews
- authority granted/delegated/revoked
- data retention/deletion events
Semantics
- Append-only: no consequential record is updated in place; corrections are new events citing the corrected one.
- Reconstructible: institutional state at any timestamp is derivable by replay — roster, agenda, obligations.
- Digest-linked: artefacts (spec versions, run outputs, recommendation text, response documents) are referenced by digest so content substitution is detectable.
- Ceremony-aware: audit bundles bind (spec digest + input digest + seed + output digest + witnesses) into one attestable unit.
- External-faithful: records of external actions cite the external system’s artefact + our observation of it — never claim the external system said more than evidenced.
What audit is not
- Not a tamper-proof claim — it is a tamper-evident record design; physical/legal custody remains institutional.
- Not an AI-checkable process — verification tooling may check digests, but attestation is a witnessed human act.