Research / architecture

Current research

CA-A1 — architecture decision register

Type: architecture Updated: 2026-10-05 Scale: cross-jurisdictional Path: ../architecture/ARCHITECTURE-DECISIONS.md

architecturedecisions

Sources: SRC-0144SRC-0145SRC-0146SRC-0147SRC-0148SRC-0149SRC-0150SRC-0152

Architecture decision register

CA-A1 architecture record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Stable CA-AD identifiers for architectural decisions already supported by accepted CA-R2/CA-R3 evidence. No database/framework/deployment technology is chosen.

IDDecisionRationaleEvidence/ReqsConsequencesRejected/deferredReversibility
CA-AD-001Cicada Assemblies owns the governed lifecycle/record spinethe unserved layer identified in CA-R3 is exactly this; all institutions need itCA-REQ-001/002; CICADA-GAPSCicada is system of record; external tools are channelscoordinator-of-platforms posture (Composition C)high — record portability preserved by export
CA-AD-002Selection algorithms are external-first, not rebuiltpublished peer-reviewed engine exists; no evidence for a new oneSELECTION-TECHNOLOGY; SRC-0145GPL-3.0 boundary must be architected; engine is replaceable behind CA-CONTRACT-SEL-001build-own-enginemoderate — adapter seam isolates
CA-AD-003Selection = governance spec → deterministic execution → witness bundlecorpus evidence: the ceremony is the institution, the maths is a componentCA-REQ-010–015; SRC-0083three artefacts always; engine pluggablesingle-run-monolith modelstructural, foundational
CA-AD-004Technical permission and institutional authority are separate objectsfacilitator-can-edit ≠ may-set-agenda; corpus capture riskCA-REQ-080–084every consequential write carries dual attributionmerged role modelstructural
CA-AD-005Consequential events require dual attribution (actor + authority artefact)makes authority gaps visible rather than silentCA-REQ-080–083audit events heavier; divergence flagging built-insingle-attributionstructural
CA-AD-006Person and membership are distinct recordssame person may serve multiple bodies/terms; privacy separationCA-REQ-025/029two object classes; joins explicitperson-with-flags modelmoderate
CA-AD-007Closed recommendations are immutablereceiving authority must not edit the record it answersCA-REQ-055amendments are new versionseditable-with-historystructural
CA-AD-008Recommendation/response/acceptance/implementation are distinct objects and statesconflation is the corpus’s main accountability failureCA-REQ-061–065four objects, visible non-responsemerged “outcome” fieldstructural
CA-AD-009Non-selected respondent data gets stronger minimisation/retentionmost sensitive silent data, no public roleCA-REQ-019; privacy classestightest retention class; deletion events recordeduniform retentionpolicy-tunable
CA-AD-010Offline acts produce equivalent canonical eventsdigital exclusion is structural; corpus parity requirementCA-REQ-071all event types have offline provenance pathonline-only UXstructural
CA-AD-011External platforms are replaceable seams, not canonical ownerscorpus landscape is fragmented; coupling risk realCA-R3 compositions A–Eall external content arrives via cited imports w/ digestcanonical-in-externalmoderate per-seam
CA-AD-012AI outputs are advisory/derivative; never institutional authorityCA-D007; authority-laundering riskCA-REQ-084; INFOSCOPE-BOUNDARYai_artefact flag; no write path to canonical recordsAI-assisted authority pathsstructural
CA-AD-013Registers/frame data stay external by defaultelectoral data custody is a liability + legitimacy boundaryPOPULATION-AND-INVITATIONCicada holds descriptors/digests; imports are explicit per-field decisionscanonical-register modelper-deployment
CA-AD-014Institution/cycle/session are three distinct object classespermanent-rotating institutions exist; cohort ≠ institutionCA-OBJ-001/003/018all lifecycle concepts attach at correct levelsingle “assembly” objectstructural
CA-AD-015Multi-level membership arrives via uniform transition eventsdelegation and fresh draw are different provenance, same objectCA-REQ-090–092; SYNTHETIC-Edelegated vs drawn members distinguishable; representativeness not composedseparate objects per mechanismmoderate

Conventions

Sources