Canonical ownership boundaries
CA-A1 architecture record. Updated: 2026-10-05. Defines what Cicada Assemblies owns canonically vs what external systems may supply.
Canonical Cicada Assemblies records (system of record)
| Object | Canonical owner | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Assembly institution | Cicada | the legal/institutional identity |
| Institutional model/configuration | Cicada | declared pattern + parameters (CA-R2 patterns A–G) |
| Eligible-population rule | Cicada | versioned artefact |
| Invitation/frame record | Cicada | frame type + coverage + weighting declaration |
| Selection specification | Cicada | the authorised governance artefact (CA-REQ-010/011) |
| Selection run record | Cicada | spec ref + input digest + output + metadata |
| Witness/audit bundle | Cicada | seed capture, witnesses, digests, verification instructions |
| Respondent-pool reference | Cicada (data may be operator-held) | pool descriptor + digest, not the data itself by default |
| Membership/cohort/term state | Cicada | statused roster history |
| Reserve/replacement events | Cicada | event records, not just a pool |
| Agenda/remit | Cicada | authorised items with provenance |
| Evidence-register references | Cicada | register + rationale; blobs may live elsewhere |
| Session/deliberation metadata | Cicada | structure + attendance + facilitation model; content may be external |
| Decision/recommendation/dissent | Cicada | the immutable record contract |
| Receiving authority | Cicada | identity + obligation declaration |
| Response obligation | Cicada | deadline + state machine |
| Response | Cicada | the response object; receiving authority authors it |
| Implementation commitment | Cicada | commitments + milestones + evidence refs |
| Follow-up/accountability record | Cicada | periodic review events |
| Delegation/nesting relationships | Cicada | multi-level structure |
| Authority artefacts | Cicada | the authority/permission separation layer |
External / non-canonical capabilities
| Capability | Candidate systems | Ownership position |
|---|---|---|
| Selection algorithm execution | sortition-algorithms (adapt), OpenDLP (integrate), Panelot (service) | engine executes; run record is canonical in Cicada; engine output imported, never authoritative until recorded |
| Mass participation | Polis, Decidim, CONSUL | channel data is external; Cicada holds a channel record + bias label + imported summaries |
| Async deliberation | Loomio | thread/poll content external; session/decision records canonical |
| Synchronous deliberation | institutional tools / Stanford ODP (unavailable) | session metadata canonical; capture external |
| Transcription/synthesis | Dembrane Echo (licence-conditional) | AI artefacts external-derived; labelled advisory, never authoritative |
| Identity provider | external IdP/census services | authentication external; authority artefacts canonical |
| Frame data (electoral/resident registers) | operator/registrar custody | never canonical in Cicada — reference/controlled import only |
Import/reference policy
- External data enters as referenced artefacts:
{external_system, external_id, digest, fetched_at}— the canonical record cites; it does not copy by default. - Imports are versioned snapshots: imported content is pinned at fetch time with digest; updates create new import versions.
- Cache policy: external content may be cached for rendering; cache is never the source of truth.
- No overwrite rule: nothing external may overwrite a closed/immutable canonical record (recommendation text, selection output, response chain).
- Digest discipline: every external artefact cited by a canonical record carries a digest so tampering is detectable.
- Respondent/frame custody: population and respondent data default to operator custody; Cicada holds descriptors, counts and digests — personal data lands in Cicada only by explicit per-field decision at implementation.