Initial landscape sweep — sortition and assemblies
Date: 2026-10-04
Status: initial research baseline; expand into dedicated records during CA-R1.
Research framing
Sortition should not be treated as one algorithm. A functioning assembly system spans at least:
- eligible population / sampling frame;
- random invitation;
- response and self-selection effects;
- stratified final selection;
- deliberation and evidence;
- recommendation/decision;
- mandate, response and accountability.
The research programme therefore covers institutions and process design as well as software.
Initial institutional examples
Ireland — Citizens’ Assemblies
Official material for the Citizens’ Assembly on Drugs Use records a 100-member assembly: an independent chair plus 99 members of the public. Postal invitations were sent to 20,000 randomly selected households; 99 public members were then selected from respondents using demographic criteria including age, gender and geography, with broader correspondence sought for socioeconomic status, ethnicity and disability.
Research importance:
- two-stage civic lottery;
- population eligibility broader than the electoral register;
- clear example of invitation versus final stratified selection.
Source: SRC-0001.
Status: full case-study record established 2026-10-04 at research/case-studies/ireland-citizens-assemblies.md (six bodies since 2012; note that the 2016-18 assembly used contracted quota recruitment with electoral-register eligibility, not the later household-invitation model).
Paris Citizens’ Assembly
Paris documents a 100-person citizens’ assembly. The third cohort began in September 2024. The city records 80 members from Paris electoral lists, 15 non-EU residents and 5 people aged 16–17, with the selection intended to represent Parisian diversity. Paris also documents public-response and follow-up mechanisms for assembly outputs.
Research importance:
- permanent/recurring municipal model;
- inclusion beyond standard electoral-roll eligibility;
- formal route from citizen work into municipal decision processes.
Status: full case-study record established 2026-10-04 at research/case-studies/paris-citizens-assembly.md (created by October 2021 council délibération; bailiff-attested draw; vœu/délibération/jury citoyen outputs; annual droit de suite tracking).
Ostbelgien / German-speaking Community of Belgium
The permanent citizens’ dialogue model is a priority case for dedicated research because it separates a continuing citizens’ council from time-limited assemblies and is frequently cited as institutionalised deliberative democracy.
Status: full case-study record established 2026-10-04 at research/case-studies/ostbelgien-permanent-citizens-dialogue.md (decree of 25 Feb 2019; National Register two-phase lottery; Bürgerrat of 24 rotating members; legally anchored follow-up with justified rejection; decree amended April 2024).
Brussels deliberative committees
Priority case for research into hybrid bodies combining randomly selected residents and elected representatives.
Status: full case-study record established 2026-10-04 at research/case-studies/brussels-deliberative-committees.md (rules amendments Dec 2019; 45+15 and 36+12 mixed committees; 1,000-signature citizen trigger; dedicated data-protection decree of 11 Feb 2022).
A separate Brussels permanent citizens’ assembly for climate was identified during this research and added to the case-study queue.
Your Party
Your Party documents a five-person Members’ Oversight Committee selected by sortition, conducted by the independent Sortition Foundation, for a temporary governance/oversight role during its transition to an elected Central Executive Committee.
Research importance:
- sortition inside a party governance structure;
- hybrid relationship between sortition and elected executive authority;
- oversight/teller role rather than legislative assembly.
This is a political-party case study and is recorded descriptively, not as endorsement.
Source: SRC-0004.
Initial practitioner/method sources
Sortition Foundation
The Sortition Foundation describes a two-stage democratic-lottery method:
- lottery-based invitations;
- representative final selection by lottery from respondents.
Its current services material says it uses demographic, socioeconomic and sometimes attitudinal targets, and that it uses its Open Democratic Lottery Platform (OpenDLP).
The organisation states that OpenDLP is open-source and was started as a multi-year development project in 2025.
Research importance:
- practitioner methodology;
- candidate reusable/open-source selection capability;
- source for recruitment, representativeness and audit questions.
Involve
Involve’s citizens’ assembly guidance treats random creation of a potential-member pool followed by random stratified sampling as a core representativeness standard. Its guidance also emphasises reimbursement, participant payment, accessibility, caring provision and facilitator ratios.
Research importance:
- operational quality criteria beyond the lottery algorithm;
- inclusion and accessibility as factors affecting actual representation.
Initial software landscape
OpenDLP
Open Democratic Lottery Platform, developed by Sortition Foundation / Sortition Lab.
Candidate role: civic-lottery workflow and representative selection.
Status: investigate source repository, licence, APIs, algorithm documentation, audit model and maturity in CA-R1/CA-R3.
Decidim
Decidim includes a reproducible sortitions component that can randomly select proposals/candidates. This is not assumed to be a complete citizens-assembly recruitment system.
Candidate role: participatory-process architecture, assemblies/proposals/meetings/accountability and reproducible randomisation patterns.
Source: SRC-0009.
Loomio
Loomio describes itself as open-source decision-making software built by a worker-owned cooperative, supporting group context, discussion, decisions and durable records.
Candidate role: asynchronous group decision/discussion patterns rather than population sampling.
Source: SRC-0010.
Further systems to investigate
- Panelot — representative-panel selection.
- Polis / Computational Democracy — large-scale opinion clustering and consensus discovery.
- CONSUL DEMOCRACY — participatory processes, proposals, debates, voting and budgeting.
- Stanford Online Deliberation Platform — structured online deliberation.
- additional civic-lottery and deliberation systems found through research.
These require dedicated verified source records before detailed claims are canonical.
Initial design questions for Cicada
The following are research questions, not approved architecture:
- Does each geographic level use a fresh population lottery, delegates from lower assemblies, or a hybrid?
- How are open assemblies related to representative mini-publics?
- Who can set an assembly’s agenda?
- What obligation does a council/government/organisation have to answer an assembly?
- How are dissent and minority reports preserved?
- How do mass-participation tools feed a small representative assembly without allowing the most active users to dominate?
- How are eligibility and identity proved without exposing participants to lobbying or unnecessary surveillance?
- Which strata are legitimate to use and who authorises them?
- How are random seeds, target definitions, substitutions and operator actions audited?
- Which capabilities belong in Cicada’s shared foundation and which must remain Assemblies-specific?
- Which existing systems should Cicada integrate instead of recreate?
Immediate CA-R1 expansion
Create dedicated records for:
- Ireland — done 2026-10-04 (
research/case-studies/ireland-citizens-assemblies.md); - Paris — done 2026-10-04 (
research/case-studies/paris-citizens-assembly.md); - Ostbelgien — done 2026-10-04 (
research/case-studies/ostbelgien-permanent-citizens-dialogue.md); - Brussels — done 2026-10-04 (
research/case-studies/brussels-deliberative-committees.md); - UK national/local examples;
- Your Party;
- Assemble / people’s assembly approaches;
- Sortition Foundation;
- Involve;
- Democracy R&D;
- newDemocracy Foundation;
- OpenDLP;
- Panelot;
- Decidim;
- CONSUL;
- Loomio;
- Polis;
- Stanford deliberation tools.
Also start theory records for:
- sortition;
- deliberative democracy;
- descriptive vs substantive representation;
- civic lotteries;
- self-selection bias;
- stratified sampling;
- institutionalisation/permanent assemblies;
- nested/federal assembly models;
- hybrid elected/sortition systems;
- legitimacy, mandate and accountability.